Built With VAs podcast

Personality Tests for Hiring Virtual Assistants: What Each One Measures and Costs

Hosted by Valentina Brega · Episode 42 · August 14, 2024 · 13 min

Valentina Brega goes through six personality tests she has used or seen used in hiring, with her cost ranges. She explains how to choose one or two, use the results in interviews, and why a test is only one step.

Watch on YouTube, or listen on Apple Podcasts and Spotify. Every episode: Built With VAs.

Valentina Brega walks through the personality tests she has used or seen used when hiring: what each one measures, how it works and what it costs. The episode title says five, but she covers six. She then explains how to pick one or two, how to use the results in an interview, and why a test is only one step in hiring.

Key takeaways

  • Valentina says personality tests give insight into how someone thinks, behaves and interacts with others, which helps when you are judging fit with your team and culture.
  • She describes six tests with her own cost ranges: Myers-Briggs ($50 to $150), DISC ($60 to $100), Enneagram ($20 to $60), Big Five ($20 to $100), Predictive Index ($250 to $500 a year for small teams) and Culture Index ($3,000 to $10,000 a year). She is not sponsored by any of them.
  • The tests measure similar things, so define the traits the role needs, choose one or two tests that match, and let budget decide.
  • Tell candidates why you are using the test, then ask whether they agree with their results. If they do not, ask questions to find out why.
  • Her team has hired people without a personality profile and regretted it. She also says never to rely on a test alone: the interview, how the person presents and reference checks all count.

About this episode

This is a solo episode of Built With VAs. Valentina describes each test briefly and says she is keeping it educational and simple. The costs are her estimates, and the descriptions come from her own experience, including a company she worked with that used Culture Index. Check current prices with each provider.

Chapters

Full transcript

Cleaned from YouTube auto-captions. Filler words and false starts are trimmed, caption errors fixed. The captions repeat the opening about a minute in, so the repeated sentences appear once here. Nothing has been added. Timestamps mark the start of each chapter.

This is a solo episode, so Valentina speaks throughout. Her first paragraph in each chapter is labelled; the rest follow as plain paragraphs.

Introduction (00:00)

Valentina Brega: If you're in the process of hiring a virtual assistant or an in-house employee, you probably know how challenging it can be to find the perfect fit. One of the best tools you can use is a personality test, because it gives you insight into who the candidate really is. So let's dive into a couple of personality tests you can use for your company. I will tell you a little detail about each of them, not to overwhelm you, but enough to give you an idea of what you want to use for your company.

What are Personality Tests? (01:22)

Valentina Brega: I actually know a lot of companies that never use personality tests, and I'm like, how do you know what this candidate can really do? Personality tests are more than a fun quiz you might take online. They give you valuable insight into how someone thinks, behaves and interacts with others. So when you're hiring a virtual assistant, understanding these aspects can make a big difference in finding someone who not only gets the job done but also fits very well with your team and your culture.

So let's explore some of the most popular personality tests that can help you make an informed hiring decision. I'm not sponsored by any of these, so this is purely educational content, and don't worry, I'll try to keep it simple and to the point.

Personality Test #1 (01:55)

Valentina Brega: The first one is the Myers-Briggs Type Indicator, or MBTI. It's all about understanding how people perceive the world and make decisions. It categorizes individuals into 16 personality types based on their preferences. For example, do they gain energy from being around people, which is extroversion, or from being alone, which is introversion? Are they more practical, which is sensing, or imaginative, which is intuition?

Here's why it's useful. Knowing your VA's MBTI type can help you understand how they process information and make decisions, which is very important for task management. For example, if you have an ISTJ, which is introverted, sensing, thinking and judging, this person might excel at administrative tasks that require meticulous attention to detail and adherence to schedules.

The test involves a series of questions about preferences in various scenarios, from decision-making to social interactions, and it helps pinpoint which of the 16 personality types someone aligns with. As for cost, it typically runs between $50 and $150, but there are free versions online that give you a pretty quick overview. The free version provides some basic information, and the paid version gives you a more detailed assessment of the candidate.

Personality Test #2 (03:13)

Valentina Brega: The second one is very popular: the DISC assessment. It looks at four main traits: dominance, influence, steadiness and conscientiousness. It helps you understand how someone might behave in a setting and how they approach tasks. Here's why it's useful. If you want a virtual assistant who pays attention to detail and works independently, someone scoring high in conscientiousness might be the best candidate. It's also particularly useful for understanding how a potential virtual assistant might interact within a team.

The way it works is also very simple. Candidates respond to statements that reflect their behavior and attitudes, and the results show which of the four traits are more dominant. That guides you in seeing how they might contribute to your team dynamic. The cost usually ranges between $60 and $100, and you can keep an eye out for bulk discounts, especially if you're testing multiple candidates. These assessments are very easy to administer and give a quick read on the candidate's behavior.

Personality Test #3 (04:14)

Valentina Brega: The third one is very useful as well, and I'm hoping I pronounce it right: the Enneagram. It explores nine personality types and focuses on motivations and emotional responses, so it's great for understanding what drives a candidate and how they handle stress. Why is it useful? If you're looking for a virtual assistant who thrives in a dynamic environment, someone who scores a type three, the achiever, could be ideal. That type tends to be success-oriented and adaptable, which is excellent for fast-paced roles. So you can see how understanding the type of personality you're looking for, and what the test offers, helps you find the best match.

The test involves introspective questions that help identify which of the nine types someone aligns with, and it offers insight into their core motivations and potential challenges. The cost is anywhere between $20 and $60, so it's definitely on the more affordable side, and it has free versions that offer basic insights as well. Free versions give you a general sense of the type, and the paid versions give a deeper dive into behavioral patterns.

Personality Test #4 (05:23)

Valentina Brega: Number four on our list is the Big Five. This test evaluates five major traits: openness, conscientiousness, extraversion, agreeableness and neuroticism. It's comprehensive and gives a good overview of how someone might behave at work. It's useful because if creativity and problem solving are important for the role, you know what kind of candidate to look for: someone with high openness. The test is highly regarded for its ability to predict job performance and team fit.

The way it works is that candidates rate how much they agree or disagree with various statements, which lets you gauge their personality across all five dimensions. It's known for its scientific rigor and broad application. As for cost, the Big Five assessment runs between $20 and $100 depending on the depth of the report. Free versions can provide a quick overview, which makes it accessible if you want a preliminary screening.

Personality Test #5 (06:31)

Valentina Brega: We have two more tests on this list, and the last one I'm very familiar with, because we used it at one of the companies I used to work for. Number five is the Predictive Index, or PI. It helps you understand a candidate's behavioral drives and cognitive abilities, and it focuses on traits like dominance and patience. It has been gaining popularity lately. It's useful because it's great for assessing fit for specific roles and predicting how a candidate might interact with others. It's particularly useful for tailoring roles to match a candidate's natural inclinations, which enhances job satisfaction and performance.

Here's how it works. The assessment involves two simple lists of adjectives. Candidates choose the words they feel describe them, and it quickly maps their behavioral style. The cost can range from $250 to $500 annually for small teams as part of a package deal. It's a more substantial investment, but it provides robust insight into team dynamics and role fit.

Personality Test #6 (07:26)

Valentina Brega: Last but not least, Culture Index, which I'm very familiar with. We actually used it at one of the companies I worked with. I know I'm a Trailblazer, and it has been very accurate for us. It's on the more expensive side, but I found it pretty accurate. It assesses how a candidate's work style aligns with your company culture, so it predicts good fit and can enhance team productivity. If you want to align a candidate's values with your team culture, it's a great tool, because once you understand a candidate's culture fit, you can see whether they would be a good addition to your company.

The way it works is very simple. You're given a list of adjectives to choose from, and you see which ones resonate with you more. Candidates complete a survey about their work preferences and behaviors, and also about themselves, so it has two components. One is to describe yourself the way you are, choosing adjectives from the list. The second is to choose the adjectives you think you need to have in order to be successful in this role. So it shows you what they're naturally good at, and what they need to work on, or think they need to work on, to be successful in the job. It provides some really good insights.

Now the cost. The subscription can range from $3,000 to $10,000 per year. It's an annual cost, so it's a significant investment for optimizing talent acquisition. Yes, it's expensive, but again, I found it to be very accurate, both for the description I got about myself and for the team members at the company I worked for. We used this tool to build a cohesive team, and we were so happy. There was no drama and everyone worked very well together. I'm not sure if it's because of the company culture or because of the personality test, but that's just my finding. Again, I'm not sponsored by any of these. It's just what I'm most familiar with because of my experience.

How to Use Tests for Hiring (09:21)

Valentina Brega: Now that you know the basics, how do you use these tests when hiring a virtual assistant? First of all, start by defining the traits that are most important for the role, and then select one or two tests that align with those characteristics. You'll notice that when I describe all these tests, they sound kind of the same. They measure how you would behave at work, what's important to you, and a lot of different traits that are pretty similar. So you just have to decide what works best for your budget and your needs. I gave a very quick description of each so you can see which one you align with most. Once you understand what kind of candidate you need, select one of these tests that aligns with those characteristics and put the virtual assistants through it.

When you give these tests, be transparent with the candidates about why you're using them. Use the results to guide your interview questions and discussions. It helps you go deeper into how a candidate's traits play out in real-world scenarios.

Importance of Personality Tests (10:05)

Valentina Brega: This is how we used to hire virtual assistants. We run a couple of personality profiles, and it also helps us understand their motivation. This is also a great point to ask them in the interview: do you agree with these results? Do you see yourself in them? If they say no, then we ask questions and try to go deeper into why we're getting these results for the candidate and why they're not aligned with what the candidate says. It's a very interesting tool, and I can tell you that a lot of the time it is very accurate.

We have hired people without looking at personality profiles, just because they had a great resume or presented themselves so well at the interview, and then the relationship didn't work. Then we looked at the personality profile and understood why it happened. We didn't know how to manage that person. We put him in a position that is very detail-oriented when he is not detail-oriented at all. Even though he had experience, and even though he said in the interview that he preferred to work with details, it shows that the way he is hardwired isn't compatible with the job we put him through. So we try to make it a habit not to hire outside of the personality profiles we really need.

But keep in mind that personality tests are just one part of the hiring process. We never hire without running a personality profile of some sort, and we also don't rely on it solely, because that could be an erroneous decision as well. We also have to take into account the whole picture of what the person can do and how they present themselves at the interview, along with the personality profile and reference checks. There's so much more that goes into finding the right person, but this is one very important step. So, like I said, encourage the candidate to share their thoughts on their test results and how they relate to their experience. This is what we do at HireTrainVA.

I hope you found that useful. Let us know in the comments which personality test you're using for your team, or which one you're planning to use and why. There are a lot of videos online about each of them that go into detail, but these are the ones I have tried or have heard about. My team actually uses them; I use them less, because I'm outside of that department. But this is something we have used to see results. Thank you for tuning in. Stay tuned for next week's episode. Bye.

Free discovery call

Not sure what you need?

Book a call. Tell us where your time goes and we will match you with a VA, an AI Employee, or a Hybrid Team of both.

Book a call →
Valentina BregaFounder of HireTrainVA · host of the Built With VAs podcast

On Built With VAs, Valentina talks with founders and operators about hiring, delegating and running a remote team, and what actually worked for them.