How to Conduct Successful Interviews for Virtual Assistants
Valentina Brega shows how HireTrainVA interviews virtual assistant candidates, from the video chat and the same-questions rule to the practical test. She covers the questions used in two interview rounds, the mistakes business owners make, the red flags to act on and why reference checks matter.
Key takeaways
- Interview on video, ask every candidate the exact same questions, and finish with a short test of the real job: a role play for a cold caller, a page review for social media, a small offline task for a video editor. Do not ask a VA to work for free.
- Record the interviews. When you rewatch with fresh eyes you can pick between two good candidates, spot red flags you missed, or show the recordings to your team.
- HireTrainVA uses two rounds. The first is a screening interview of about 20 minutes with four questions from the book Who. The second goes into experience, accomplishments, low points, why they left and the metrics they reported.
- Common mistakes: being afraid to ask tough questions, buying without testing, running long interviews for bad candidates, not recording, analysis paralysis and looking for an exact replica of a past hire.
- Red flags named in the episode: arriving late, excuses instead of solutions, job bouncing, an attitude or ego problem, and a bad feeling you cannot shake. Check references before you hire.
About this episode
This is a solo episode of Built With VAs. Valentina Brega describes how HireTrainVA structures its interviews, and says she is showing what the agency does behind the curtain. It follows the episode on writing a job ad. She mentions one book, Who: The A Method for Hiring by Geoff Smart and Randy Street, as the source of the screening questions.
Chapters
- 00:00 Introduction
- 00:32 Why Interviews are Crucial?
- 01:09 Interview Structure
- 04:12 Delegate to an Expert
- 07:03 First Round Interview Questions
- 11:12 Second Round Interview Questions
- 12:29 Mistakes Entrepreneurs Make in the Interviews
- 16:21 Interview Red Flags
- 20:03 Checking References
- 20:47 Go Find the Best Candidates
Full transcript
Cleaned from YouTube auto-captions. Filler words and false starts are trimmed, caption errors fixed, speakers labelled from context. Nothing has been added. Timestamps mark the start of each passage.
Introduction (00:00)
Valentina Brega: Hi everyone, welcome to the show Built With VAs. I'm your host, Valentina Brega, and today we're talking about how to interview virtual assistants. If you follow this podcast, last time we spoke about how to write a job ad that doesn't suck. If you haven't seen it, make sure to go back and watch it. Now that you've found the perfect candidates that you think may be good for you, let's see how you interview them to really understand whether or not they're the right fit for your company. Let's get right to it. It's going to be awesome.
Why Interviews are Crucial? (00:32)
Valentina Brega: Interviewing people is one of the best ways to understand if that person is the right fit for you. I like this process, I like the interview. But I have to be careful here, because a lot of candidates have crafted the art of the perfect interview, and you can fall in love with a candidate at the interview. They can have the right resume and the right interview. But there are some questions we ask, and a way we structure our interviews here at HireTrainVA, that help us get a better understanding of the candidates. That's what I want to show you today.
Interview Structure (01:09)
Valentina Brega: We're going to talk about the red flags, we're going to talk about our structure, and I'm going to show you behind the curtain what we do in our agency. When you interview candidates, always have a video chat. There are a couple of reasons for that. Some candidates prefer a phone interview, and that's okay if there's no other alternative, but I prefer a video chat because you can see the person's body language, you can see how they react, and you can see the quality of their internet connection. That's important, because a lot of the programs will lag or there will be some issues on a video chat. It's a great way to check the internet speed and make sure they have the right equipment to do a good job for you, especially for a remote position, and especially for virtual assistants who are on the other side of the world, where you're not sure whether they have reliable technology. Like I said, it's also important to see the person's body language and how they carry themselves.
I recently interviewed someone I was considering for my own company. She came highly recommended, with a high position at a good, very famous company. When we interviewed, I understood within the first minute that this was not the person I wanted. She did not present herself professionally, the answers were not good, and the video chat wasn't good. I knew from the first minute, and I don't think I would have reached that conclusion on a phone interview. So my recommendation is always to have a video chat.
The next thing is to ask the exact same questions of everyone. You want to compare apples to apples. I'm going to show you a book we use and the questions we ask. When you ask the same questions, you get to see how different the responses can be, how deeply some people go and how superficially others answer, and that tells you a lot.
The next thing is to give a test. After you've conducted the interview, don't just take it at face value. Put it to a little test. Have a little role play. If you're hiring someone for cold calling, put them in uncomfortable situations, if their job requires it. Especially in real estate, you know how those prospects can be. They can be brutal out there. So in a cold calling session, you don't want to be the nicest person on the phone. You want to give them tough objections, because you want to see how that virtual assistant handles the heat and being put under pressure. It's also good for virtual assistants to see whether they can take the heat, and whether this is really the position they want to work in, dealing with this every day for eight hours a day. It's a perfect way to put them to a little test.
If you hire someone for social media, show them very quickly a page on Instagram and say: tell me everything you can about this page. What do you like, what do you not like, what would you change and how?
Delegate to an Expert (04:12)
Valentina Brega: You probably have some idea about what would work well for social media. You want a person who knows more than you. You want to delegate up, to an expert. If I hear a very superficial answer, this is not the person I want to hire. What I want to hear is: let me see your hashtags, let me see your description, you're not very searchable, let me see your analytics, I don't think you have enough reels. Why don't your reels have captions? Don't you know a lot of people scroll social media without audio? I would highly encourage you to have captions, so people can scroll and still get your message. These are the kind of responses I would love to hear if I'm hiring someone for social media: someone who really understands and can prove it to me at the interview, right then and there, without any preparation, because they really are an expert.
If you hire a video editor, give them a quick little video to edit, which can be done offline after the interview. Give them a deadline. I always say this: don't ask the VA to work for free, and don't give them a task that's going to take hours or a whole day. Just give them a little task so you understand what they can do for your specific project. The truth is, not a lot of people will actually do it. A lot of people will bail, but that's another level of filtration to see whether this person is a great fit. If you want to test something at the interview, you can also show them a quick video and ask: tell me what you like about this video, what you don't like, what would you change? I want to hear someone say, this is the wrong audio for this, the audio doesn't convey the right emotion. If it's a sad video, I want to hear something more [unclear]. The transition is not smooth, the color grading is not there. I want to hear what they sound like as an expert.
So you get the idea. At an interview, have a video chat, ask the same questions, and toward the end always give a test. This is all high-level information. Last but not least, record the interviews. This is important for a couple of reasons. Sometimes you can't decide between two good candidates, and when you step back and take a look at the interviews again with fresh eyes, you'll see who the better candidate is. Other times you fall in love with a candidate right after the interview, but when you take some time and look at it with fresh eyes, you start to see red flags, or you get confirmation that this is the best person for you. In any case, record the interviews, watch them and see the candidate with fresh eyes. If you have a couple of people, you get to choose who to hire, or you can show the recordings to someone else on the team and make sure everybody agrees on the right person to bring on board.
First Round Interview Questions (07:03)
Valentina Brega: That's what you do at an interview at a high level. Now let's go a little deeper. When we interview candidates at HireTrainVA, we have two rounds. The first one is very simple and basic. We just want to identify the A players from the rest, very quickly, and it takes about 20 minutes. The second interview is where we go granular into their expectations, their experience, their metrics, why they left the previous job and so on.
If you have a lot of candidates, you don't want to waste your time and book a whole hour with everyone. You quickly want to decide who's going to be a better fit and who needs to go right away. So we use the strategy from this book called Who. The first interview is a screening interview, and there are four questions you ask candidates. You see how they respond.
Question one: what are your career goals? I want to see if they've really thought about this and whether their career aligns with my job. Is my job just a pit stop in their career, something they'll do for a few months before they leave, or are we aligned, and can I help this person grow and become better?
Question two: what are you really good at professionally? I want them to brag, and tell me what they can bring to the table and how they can help my company.
Question three: what are you bad at professionally? I want them to be honest with me and with themselves. A lot of people will say, "I'm actually pretty good at everything." That's not the case. I also don't like answers that are canned and overly rehearsed, like "my weakness is that I'm a perfectionist." Okay, get over it. I need real answers. What are you not good at, so I don't put you in that position? In my case, my weakness, so to speak, is that I'm not a detail-oriented person. I'm a big visionary. Show me the vision, show me the goal, show me the end, but do not lose me in all these details and minutiae. That doesn't work for me. If I were put in a position where I'd have to do administrative work, I would not shine. Put me in a leadership or management position and I'd enjoy it more. But doing routine, detailed tasks every single day, I would lose my mind. So I would say: I'm not very detail-oriented, I don't prefer routine work, but I do love to manage and lead a team. I'm looking for realistic answers about what the person excels at professionally and what they're bad at professionally. It also shows me how well they know themselves and how comfortable they are talking about it. I don't want them to just say something bad and leave it at that. They can say something bad, but also show me what they're good at, in which positions they'd be happy and bring the most value.
Question four is a crucial one: when we talk to your former bosses, how would they rate you on a scale from 1 to 10, and what would they say about you? Why do we ask this? We're setting the expectation that we're going to call your former bosses. And you get to see how they react, their body language. Maybe they were let go, or maybe the relationship with their former boss wasn't good. You also get to see how diplomatically they respond and how they act in an uncomfortable situation. Are they badmouthing that company, or are they still taking the high road and finding the positive, spinning it in a good way? It shows how they would present your company if something didn't go well. It's all about being professional, but also about how they think and about their personality.
Second Round Interview Questions (11:12)
Valentina Brega: That's the first screening round. When you go into the second round, that's where you go deeper. I'm going to put a few questions on the screen, and if you're listening rather than watching, I'll read them out loud. What were you hired to do in your previous job? What accomplishments are you proud of? What were the low points during your job? Why did you leave your job? Tell me about a person you admire and why you like them. And what metrics did you have to report, and how did you perform?
That last question is not from the book. We add more questions depending on the role we hire for, but this is a great way to start getting granular into their previous experience. I want to know what they're proud of, what accomplishments they have, what brought them satisfaction and what they'd love to do again to replicate that good feeling. What were the low points? Is it something I can avoid as a leader, because I want to keep my people happy? Why did they leave their previous job? Is it something I can avoid, so I don't make the same mistake? Or was it an integrity issue, in which case that would be a huge red flag? Besides these, we ask more specific questions related to the job. If someone is applying as an executive assistant, we ask them to tell us about a situation where they had to do this or that, or to show us their skill set.
Mistakes Entrepreneurs Make in the Interviews (12:29)
Valentina Brega: All right, let's move on. There are a couple of mistakes that business owners make in an interview. They're so common. Maybe people don't realize they're making them, or they're being so nice that they don't want to offend anyone.
The number one mistake is being too afraid to ask tough questions. Tough questions are important, because you uncover red flags, you get clarification on situations, you uncover their concerns and you get to know them deeply as people. A lot of interviewers want to be nice and don't want to scare away good candidates, so they're afraid to ask. That's a common mistake.
Another mistake is that they don't test what they buy. We already talked about this, and I talk about it a lot. Before you offer the job to someone, really know what the person can do for you. Don't ask the VA to work for free, but test their knowledge and see what they can do for your product, your service, your situation. Have them do a cold call, or analyze a Facebook or Instagram page. Do not buy without testing first.
Another mistake is long interviews for bad candidates. If you know this is a bad candidate, protect your time and your energy. You can spend your time better doing something else. And let the candidate know right away: this is not what I'm looking for. I personally don't like telling people "we'll be in touch." I like to tell them exactly whether or not they passed the interview, because I don't want more emails from people following up. I keep it short: thank you so much for showing up, but unfortunately we're looking for something else, I wish you all the best of luck, I want to respect your time as well, and I don't think you would be happy here because we're looking for a different skill set. That's it. Keep it short. Don't keep candidates on at the interview just out of niceness.
The next mistake is not recording the interviews. We talked about this. Definitely record them so you can choose between candidates and get a lot more clarity.
The next one is analysis paralysis, and this is huge. So many entrepreneurs are looking for the perfect VA. Maybe you know somebody who has an amazing virtual assistant or an amazing employee, and you want to find the exact replica of that person. But what you don't know is that people grow into their roles. When I was first hired by a real estate company, I was not very good. I'm actually surprised they gave me the opportunity. I knew absolutely nothing about real estate, and I had to learn everything on the go. Eventually I got to be pretty decent at the job, but that was not the person they initially hired.
So when you're looking to hire the perfect virtual assistant, that doesn't exist. What if they're so money motivated that they leave you in a month because someone else offered them a dollar more per hour? You never know what's going to happen, and you've just wasted all this time, energy and resources on training. Instead, what if you find the right personality and teach them the skill set? Of course you want somebody with experience, but you also want someone who's coachable and who'll get it fast. When you identify the right personality, this hunger, this coachability, this desire for more, this go-getter quality and assertiveness, you can put them in any position and they'll figure it out. That's what you're looking for, and that's how you get the perfect VA. You might find the perfect VA right away, but don't count on it. Too many people are paralyzed by analysis. They're always looking for something better and better while their business is on hold. That's a common mistake.
The next one is that they look for the exact replica, which is what we just talked about. Do not look for the exact replica. People grow into their roles.
Interview Red Flags (16:21)
Valentina Brega: Now let's talk about what some red flags are when you interview people, how to identify that this person is no bueno, not going to be good for us, and needs to be let go immediately.
First of all, the candidate is late for the interview. If you, the business owner or manager, a busy entrepreneur, are on time and dressed professionally, and the candidate is late, no matter what the excuse, I don't think that's a good sign. Maybe some excuses are fine, and you can give them a second chance, but if it happens again, there's absolutely no way you can work with that person. If the excuse is "I wasn't sure of the time difference, I thought it was an hour earlier," well, there are so many tools right now. You can have reminders on your phone. There are so many ways not to make that mistake. If you want to give them a chance you can, but do not give them more than one chance, and that goes for everyone. We're human and it can happen, but in my books it's still a little red flag.
Next, they find excuses rather than solutions. This is a big red flag. You want to hire a virtual assistant or an employee who is going to make your life easier, not more complicated. If you don't feel that person is going to make your life easier, if they find excuses and not solutions, why even bring them on board? Everything is figureoutable. We don't lack resources, we lack resourcefulness. There are so many resources at our fingertips: YouTube, Google, books, everything. Find the solution, don't find an excuse.
Next red flag: job bouncing. When we hire virtual assistants, we look at their resumes. If they work two months here, two months there, two months somewhere else, and they don't stay with one company for at least one year, that's a huge red flag. A couple of experiences like that here and there are okay, but if it's a pattern, if it happens continuously, this is clearly a candidate issue and not a company issue. You risk investing a lot of time and effort into training the person, and then they leave you in a couple of months. Not a very good experience, and not the best candidate.
Next, attitude and ego problems. I don't know if I should even discuss this. If a person has an attitude or an ego problem, how can you not see that as a red flag? Why even consider having this person on board? They need to go. We are a recruiting company. We hire lots of virtual assistants for companies, and we take a lot of the heavy work and headache from companies looking to hire a VA. We talk to so many virtual assistants, and yes, there are people with a huge attitude and a huge ego problem. We're just so happy that our clients didn't have to go through that, because we identify them right away and never want to work with them again. If they have an attitude or are disrespectful, absolutely don't tolerate it. You get what you tolerate.
The last one is if you have a bad feeling overall. The VA should make your life easier. If you're not feeling it, if you're thinking "hmm, I'm not convinced," there's something in your gut telling you this is not your person, then don't go with that person. It has to be a "hell yes" or a no, so if it's not a "hell yes," it's probably a no. However, be careful, because you might miss out on some good candidates if you're infatuated with the resume or the perfect interview. You never know a person 100 percent until you actually get to work with them. Those are the red flags a lot of people should watch for, and that covers what we do here at HireTrainVA.
Checking References (20:03)
Valentina Brega: After the interview, it's always a good idea to check references. We always check the references of the people we interview, to make sure we're looking not just at their skill set but also at their personality and integrity. We've dodged a couple of bullets before. It's very important to talk to previous employers. And if you're an employer yourself and somebody calls you asking for a reference, please be unbiased and provide the right references.
Why is that important? First of all, it helps the company hiring, and it helps us know we can make good matches. But it also helps protect the VAs who are really serious about it and really want to make a difference. There are so many talented virtual assistants who want a chance and want to stand out. Maybe they don't present themselves so well in an interview. When we check references and learn more about their work ethic, their integrity and their results, that's what really matters. I really want to know what this person can do, not how well they interview or how well they crafted their resume. There are AI tools that can make a perfect resume in minutes. That's not why we hire people. We hire based on what they can do. So when you check references and give unbiased and truthful opinions, it really helps the best virtual assistants out there who want to make a difference in their own lives and a big impact in your business.
Go Find the Best Candidates (20:47)
Valentina Brega: If you need help hiring virtual assistants, we're always available. Check the links in the description for how to get in touch. Let's have a conversation, no strings attached. Let's just see what we can do for you. If it's a fit, great. If it's not, that's perfectly okay. Thank you for tuning in. Go get the perfect candidates. Now we know how to write the job title and how to interview people, so there's nothing stopping you from finding the right candidate. Go get them. They're out there, hoping to be hired by you. Thank you for tuning in. I'll see you next week.
Related episodes
- 10 Interview Questions to Find and Hire A-Players for Your Team
- 7 Hiring Red Flags You Need to Know Before You Hire Anyone
- 10 Ways to Test Your Virtual Assistant (Before You Hire One)
Related on HireTrainVA
Not sure what you need?
Book a call. Tell us where your time goes and we will match you with a VA, an AI Employee, or a Hybrid Team of both.

