10 Interview Questions to Find and Hire A-Players for Your Team
Valentina Brega shares the ten questions she asks in interviews to tell her A players from everyone else. For each question she explains why she asks it and gives a bad answer and a good answer, so you can use the same questions when you hire.
Key takeaways
- Listen to how a candidate answers, not only what they say. Valentina looks for genuine answers over canned ones, and for how a person frames a bad experience.
- Ask what they know about your company. She wants people who want this job, not people who applied everywhere, and a candidate who has not looked at your website or channel is a red flag for her.
- Ask what they have done in the last 12 months to improve their skills. Coachability is one of her core values, and she passes on candidates who say they have nothing left to learn.
- Ask "how long are you planning on working with me" and "if I hired you today, how would you be an asset?" The first shows how long you can count on someone, and the second shows their confidence in the role.
- Back the interview with the resume. She asks specific questions about what is written there, and expects stories, facts and numbers behind it.
About this episode
This is a solo episode of Built With VAs. Valentina says people often tell her that her VAs are amazing and ask how she found them, so she walks through the exact questions she asks at the interview. She explains the reason behind each one, then gives a bad answer and a good answer as examples. She also draws on her own earlier job qualifying real estate leads to show what a confident answer to the "how would you be an asset" question sounds like. The episode ends with how she follows up on the resume and what she looks for beyond the ten questions.
Chapters
This episode was published without a chapter list, so these chapter titles are ours.
- 00:00 Introduction
- 00:50 Questions 1 to 3: why they left, what they liked, what they know about you
- 05:00 Questions 4 and 5: skills for the role and skills not on the resume
- 07:45 Question 6: tell me about yourself
- 09:30 Question 7: what have you done to improve your skills
- 11:30 Question 8: how long are you planning on working with me
- 13:00 Questions 9 and 10: being an asset, and adapting to change
- 17:00 How she uses the answers
Full transcript
Cleaned from YouTube auto-captions. Filler words and false starts are trimmed, caption errors fixed, speakers labelled from context. Nothing has been added. Timestamps mark the start of each passage.
Introduction (00:00)
Valentina Brega: Hey, what's up everyone, welcome to Built With VAs. I'm Valentina Brega, and if you watch this show you know that here we talk about everything related to scaling your business. We talk about how to hire A players, how to manage them, how to train them, sales, marketing. I have awesome guests here and there's so much more to share with you. But in this episode I'm going to show you how I found my team of A players. People ask me all the time, "Your VAs are amazing, how did you find them? What did you do?" I'm going to share exactly what questions I ask them at the interview to identify the A players from everyone else. I'm going to show you the question, show you why I'm asking that question, and give you a bad and a good example. This is what really helps me identify the top of the top candidates, and I hope you can do that in your company as well and use this information. So without further ado, let's go.
Questions 1 to 3: why they left, what they liked, what they know about you (00:50)
Valentina: Okay, so here are the 10 questions that help me secure good hires. Question number one: why did you leave a previous job, or why are you leaving your company now? Why am I asking this? I want to see the candidate's attitude towards work. I want to know what's important to them, how they handle adversity, and how they talk about previous companies. Also, very important, I want to know the reason they left, if that's something I can offer them, if I can meet their needs that the previous company couldn't.
A bad example, or a red flag, would be something like, "Well, I just had to leave the company because it was such a toxic environment and I didn't get along with my co-workers, and oh my God, I just had to get away from that." Obviously this is bad. A good example is anything that's genuine. I don't want a canned response. I'm actually very against canned responses in an interview, because I don't think they're genuine. A good response here would be something genuine and tactful, even if they did have a bad experience, even if they worked in a toxic environment. It's not what happens to you but how you react to it. I want to see the personality of that candidate, how they handle rejection, how they handle adversity, what they did to overcome a toxic environment or a problem in the company. Even if that's the response they've given me, it's how they package it, how they frame it, that makes them stand out.
The second question is: what did you like about a previous job? The reason I'm asking is that I want to know what is important to that candidate. What tasks do they like, what do they enjoy, what brought them happiness in a work environment? To me this is important because I want to know if my company can offer this to them, or could at some point. Let's say somebody really enjoyed being in a leadership position but isn't applying for a leadership role now. In my mind, if that person likes being a leader, they're going to do everything they can to prove they deserve a position of leadership, which means they'll prove themselves and do the work. They want to grow, they have a growth mindset, and I can eventually put them in a leadership position. That also helps me understand where my company is growing with this person in-house. So "what did you like about your previous job" can open a lot of opportunities to see how that person fits into your company now or in the future.
A bad example would be, "I didn't really like much about that job, I was just there for the paycheck, to be honest with you." A huge red flag. A good example is what they say and how they answer, but also how they react, how their face lights up when they talk about it. They could say something like, "I loved working on big projects with my amazing team. I had a wonderful team, and together we had a project with very close deadlines. We all worked together, we all had to figure out solutions, and it brought me so much joy when we could finish the project on time and on budget and everything was smooth." That's a very good response. Again, you see the attitude and the personality behind the answer.
Question number three is: what do you know about us, or our company? Why am I asking this? I think it's obvious. I want people who want to work with me. I want people who want this job I'm offering. If they applied anywhere, if they just read the job description and thought, "Yeah, that's pretty good," and applied, it doesn't tell me they want to stay in this company. What if they just applied everywhere? That's not my goal for the company, and it's not aligned with their goal for themselves.
A bad answer here would be, "Oh, I don't really know much about your company, I haven't researched, but maybe you can tell me what exactly you do here." That would be a huge red flag for me. It's kind of like dating. Say two people go on a date and one says, "So what did you like about my profile? Why did you invite me out?" and the other says, "To be honest, I saw so many people, I don't really know why I invited you, I just thought, why not." That's not something you want to hear from your date, right? So why would it be different in a company? I want you to tell me why you want to work with us. Do some research, know what we stand for, know our core values. Everything is available on the website or on our YouTube channel. There is so much information about any company, and I want the person to really want this.
A good answer would be something like, "I loved your YouTube channel, I love the podcast, I love your website, everything looks great. And I love the fact that you talk about your team so highly. That means everyone who works with you is happy in the role, they are thriving, they are having good results, and they never want to leave." To me that's important because it shows stability, it shows professionalism, it shows a wonderful work environment, and that's exactly what I'm looking for. That's a very good answer, and I want that person to work with me.
Questions 4 and 5: skills for the role and skills not on the resume (05:00)
Valentina: All right, let's go. The next question I ask is: what skills do you have that make you a perfect match for this role? The reason I ask is that I want to know whether the candidate understands the role, and see how they can apply those skills to our role. If they tell me about other skills completely unrelated to the role I'm asking about, then it's probably not going to be a good match, or maybe they don't take it seriously. Again, look at how they respond, not just the words they say but how they respond.
A bad answer would be, "I don't really have skills that would be a good match, but I'm a fast learner. I really need experience, I can't find a job anywhere without experience, so I'm looking for a place where I can gain experience." That's a completely different topic, what to do if a candidate doesn't have experience, and I don't want to go too much into it here. A good answer would be something like, "Look, this is what you need. You need somebody to handle this project, you need somebody to do A, B and C. That's exactly what I did in my previous job, and in fact this is the result I got when I did A, this is the result I got for B, and this is what I got for C. So I think my skills are very valuable to your organization, and I also want to learn from you because of such and such." I want the candidate to tell me what they can give me but also what I can give to them. It's a two-way street. I don't hear this answer a lot, but if I do, I know this is a person worth talking to, and I'm definitely going to consider this candidate.
Question number five, because we talked about skills, is: do you have any other skills that were not mentioned on your resume or in the job description? The reason I'm asking is that I want to see potential. I want to see what this person can do that maybe I haven't thought of. Let's say this person is very skilled in social media. That's not exactly the position they're applying for, but they could add value for me down the road. I just want a good understanding of what this candidate can do and what fuels them.
A bad answer would be, "No, no other skills, that pretty much covers it, I guess." A good answer would be something like, "Well, I'm so glad you asked. In addition to the skills I have here, I didn't put everything on my resume because I wanted to keep it very tailored to this job. But I love social media, I understand analytics, I have a very analytical mind, I understand numbers, I understand traffic. I would love to maybe one day get to that position, but right now, since I applied to this role, I'm hoping to also add some of that data analysis into my new job."
Question 6: tell me about yourself (07:45)
Valentina: Question number six is probably the simplest question, but the one where people have the hardest time. The question is: tell me about yourself. I'm asking because I want to know what that person can do and who they are on a personal level, not necessarily a professional one. I want to know what hobbies they have, what fuels them. I'm going to spend eight hours a day working with that person, so obviously we need to enjoy each other's company. To me this is a very important question, even if you're working remotely, even if we work virtually.
A bad answer, and this is something I typically see, is when people tell me everything from their resume. I have the resume in front of me, so just tell me something that's not on the resume. Connect person to person, human to human. That's what I really like to see. Instead, a lot of the time I hear where they went to school, how they liked it or didn't, that they worked from this year to this year in this job, then moved to this job, and what they did here and what they did there. I think what people are missing is that when an interviewer asks "tell me about yourself," I want to know who you are and how you can help me. So tell me about your experience, but through the lens of what I need to hear and how you can add value to me. Not a lot of people get it. If you're applying for a job in finance, talk about what gets you excited about finance, or when you knew you wanted a job in finance, and why you chose your previous job in finance. Again, what value can you bring me, and show me that you're passionate about the job you're applying for. That's not something I see a lot.
Question 7: what have you done to improve your skills (09:30)
Valentina: Question number seven is probably one of my favorites: what have you done in the last 12 months to improve your skills? I ask this because coachability is very important to me. It's one of my core values. I love working on myself, personally and professionally. I want to be better, and I want people in my corner and in my company who have the same core values.
A bad answer is if someone tells me, "Look, I have 10 years of experience, I don't think I need to improve anything else in my skills, I've got this. I don't read books or follow those gurus. My 10 years of experience is much better than anything you can find online." Even if they are so good, even if they're the best candidates, it's the attitude I don't like. I know people in my network who are very successful multi-millionaires, and they all have one thing in common: they all want to work on themselves, they want to improve their skills, they are never satisfied with the level where they are right now, and they want to be better and better. If the candidate applying to work with me doesn't see things the same way and is very okay being where they are, there's always going to be someone better than them, someone who works harder and has more knowledge, and I don't want that kind of person on my team.
A good answer would be something like, "In the last 12 months I read this awesome book about how to be more productive," or "I found this amazing technique that I'm implementing right now, and it improves my productivity three times, and this is exactly what I do. I also like to follow this person on YouTube, I attend seminars, I take courses, because I believe in self-improvement and I want to be better and better at my craft." So always get a person who is coachable. If someone is against being coachable, they're not trainable. Do not get that person on board. It's not going to work in the long run.
Question 8: how long are you planning on working with me (11:30)
Valentina: The next question is a little untraditional, but I ask it directly. I say, "So how long are you planning on working with me?" A lot of the time candidates are taken aback because they don't expect that question. They're like, "Oh, how long?" Yes, how long do you plan to work with me? I want to ask this because maybe they have plans for the future, and if they're honest and genuine they'll say, "Well, actually I'm only available for six months, until I start university," or "until I have to relocate," or something like that. Then that gives me an understanding of how long I can count on that person. Sometimes I discover reasons and a different aspect of that person just by asking, "Hey, how long are you planning on staying with me?"
A good answer is someone who says, "I see myself working in a good company long term. I'm not the type of person who likes instability. I like stability. I like to know I can count on a company that can provide for me and my family and that provides a good work experience as well. So as long as I can stay." I actually have one VA in my company who says, "I'm going to stay with you until I retire. I'm not planning on going anywhere. I'm going to stay with you until I retire." That's the kind of attitude and the kind of answer I want to see.
But if the answer is something like, "Oh well, I'm not really sure, I guess we'll see how it goes, I'm keeping my options open, and I left my previous job because, well, you pay better, so I guess I'm staying here for a while," I don't want to be seen as just a company that pays better, because there will always be another company that pays even more than I can. I don't want that to be the main reason candidates choose to work with us. It's not only about money. I want candidates to feel like they're being taken care of, like they're being respected, like they enjoy the work they do. So just ask this question, "How long are you planning on staying with me?" and see how your candidates react. It will tell you a lot about that person.
Questions 9 and 10: being an asset, and adapting to change (13:00)
Valentina: Now, the next question, depending on the role I hire for, I change a little bit, but the idea is this: if I hired you today, show me exactly how you would be an asset for my company. What exactly would you do? I'm asking because I want to see their level of confidence in the job they're applying for. I want to find a person who says, "Great, you asked me to be your administrative assistant, this is exactly how I'm going to do this. I'll take care of your email, I'll make sure there are no unread messages, I'll make sure you know all the important emails you have to answer, and I'll make sure your calendar is up to date. I will make sure you don't miss any appointment, I'll remind you of that." Basically, I want that person to be so confident in the role that they can talk about it in their sleep.
In my previous job I worked as a person who qualified real estate leads. If I were to apply for a job like that again and someone asked, "How would you be beneficial for my company if I hired you? How would you help us?" I would be able to answer just like that. "Look, in my previous experience this is what I did to qualify leads, and that's exactly what I'm going to do for you. I'm going to make sure no leads are left behind, I'll always stay on top of follow-ups, I want to make sure I answer new leads right away so we get to the list very fast." This is exactly what I did, and I feel so confident I can do this for you. That's the kind of attitude I want to see. If the person who is asked that question doesn't know how to handle it, or has to think about it, or is unsure, then I don't think they are prepared to work for my company. I think I'm going to have to pour a lot into that person, I'm going to have to train them and train them until hopefully one day they are at the level I need them to be. So if you're looking for an expert right away, give them a challenging task and ask them a challenging question and see how they respond. An expert will know very quickly and very surely how to respond to a question like that.
So that's it, and the last question I ask is: tell me about a time when you had to adapt to a change in a company. It sounds like such an easy question, but again I get candidates who get stuck when they answer it. Why am I asking? Look at what happened in the previous years. Businesses overall had so many changes with COVID. We all had to go and work virtually, this closing and that closing, and businesses had to adapt. Especially if you're a small business, or even a big business, you have to change to meet market requirements. But especially if you're a small business and you're still pivoting and trying to find your niche, you want to work with people who are okay with change, and who have the confidence that they will help you no matter what you go through.
A bad answer would be something like, "I don't really like change, because it causes me a lot of stress. I remember one time when I worked with a company and we had to work on this important project and it was so stressful. It was a very nerve-wracking period in my life, and I don't really like change." I appreciate the honesty, but I don't think this person would handle the pressure of working in my company. A good answer would be something like, "Well, you know what, the way businesses operate right now, change is expected. You can't assume that nothing is going to change. It's like working out: you need to put a little pressure on to have the muscles grow. It's the same in a work environment. If we don't have adversity, we don't know how strong we become. Actually, I remember one project we worked on. It was kind of stressful, but we all pulled our efforts together and worked hard to achieve that goal, and in the end we felt such relief knowing we handled the project very well and the customer was so happy. So yes, change is to be expected. I guess we just have to be creative at the time and think about how we can save the situation rather than falling into despair." An answer like that is good enough to tell me how this person thinks and whether or not I want them in my company.
How she uses the answers (17:00)
Valentina: So here you have it. These are my 10 top questions that I ask in an interview. Depending on the conversation, I ask additional questions, I ask for clarification, I ask for examples. Another thing I do is, if I see something on the resume, I ask a specific question about it. If they can't answer that, I'm assuming maybe they lied on the resume or they're not exactly truthful there. So everything I see on the resume, they have to back up with stories, with facts, with numbers. That's another thing I look at when I hire my team, and everyone on my team, again, they are wonderful, wonderful people, and they all passed this little test. And it works, it really works. The people I had to let go before, I actually did that before I implemented this system. Now that I'm thinking about this, they wouldn't even make the cut. So anyway, there you go. I hope you enjoyed this, and I hope you can take these questions and implement them in your business right now. All right, thanks for joining me today, I'll see you next time.
Related episodes
- How to Conduct Successful Interviews for Virtual Assistants
- 7 Hiring Red Flags You Need to Know Before You Hire Anyone
- Personality Tests for Hiring Virtual Assistants: What Each One Measures and Costs
Related on HireTrainVA
Not sure what you need?
Book a call. Tell us where your time goes and we will match you with a VA, an AI Employee, or a Hybrid Team of both.

