Sorting Through 100+ Applications? Here's How to Find the Perfect Fit Fast
Valentina Brega, founder of HireTrainVA, explains how her company screens hundreds of applications quickly. She sets out a funnel in four cuts: who followed the instructions, who sent a voice recording or portfolio, whose resume holds up, and who completes a skill test. Only then does anyone get an interview.
Key takeaways
- Put an instruction in the job ad, such as a subject line that names the applicant's favorite core value. Delete everyone who did not follow it, unopened, and do not give second chances.
- Ask for proof of the work before you read a resume: a voice recording for voice roles, a portfolio or samples for roles such as social media, copywriting or video editing. You can judge it in five to ten seconds.
- Resume red flags she names: no months in the dates, a pattern of stays of two months, overlapping jobs, a poor format, and a long list of unrelated skills when you need a specialist. She raises each at the interview and checks references for the ones she likes.
- Give a short skill test before any interview. Most shortlisted candidates will not finish it, and that saves you the time of chasing them.
- By her count, if 100 people apply, you may be left with eight to ten for interviews at best. She sends the test without a deadline to see how long people take.
About this episode
This is a solo episode of Built With VAs, recorded by Valentina Brega. She describes her own company's screening process, which she says handles many applicants for each role, and she points to earlier episodes on job ads and skill tests. The episode is Episode 45, published September 5, 2024, and runs about 16 minutes.
Chapters
This episode was published without a chapter list, so these chapter titles are ours.
- 00:00 A flooded inbox and why resumes come last
- 01:30 Cut one: did they follow the instructions?
- 03:40 Cut two: voice recording, portfolio or samples
- 06:15 Cut three: resume red flags in dates and job history
- 10:10 Resume red flags in format and focus
- 13:20 Cut four: the skill test
- 15:00 Interview only the shortlist
Full transcript
Cleaned from YouTube auto-captions. Filler words and false starts are trimmed, caption errors fixed, speakers labelled from context. Nothing has been added. Timestamps mark the start of each passage.
A flooded inbox and why resumes come last (00:00)
Valentina Brega: How do I find the right person? My inbox is flooded with applications, I don't have time to screen through all of them, what do I do? The mistake most people make is that when somebody applies, the first thing they do is look at the resume, because they don't have anything else to work with. In today's episode we will look at how to screen through hundreds of applications fast and efficiently, to get you the best talent that is out there. So let's get right to it.
Since you clicked on this episode, I guess you are in the process of hiring the right teammate. Maybe it's a virtual assistant, maybe it's an employee for your company, and you came here to get some answers. Welcome to this episode of the show Built With VAs. I'm your host, Valentina Brega.
If you know a little about our company, I am the owner of HireTrainVA. You can imagine that we have so many applicants, so many candidates sending out resumes and tests. I have a whole team buzzing and working very hard just to find those two or three good candidates out of the hundreds of people we interview. I'll let you in on a little secret: the majority of people who apply to work with us are not good enough for our company, so we have to be very tough in our screening process. I'm going to share exactly what we look at, and this is where the fun begins. I'm not talking about how to write a job ad, because that's an art in itself. This is about once you've got people to apply: how do you find the right person?
Cut one: did they follow the instructions? (01:30)
Valentina Brega: The number one thing you're going to do relates to the job post. If you watched my previous episodes, you know that ideally you want something unique in the job post. What we do at our company is say: put this in the subject line, "My favorite core value is," and then your favorite core value. We use core values because they are so important to us as a company, and even in the job ad we already say what we stand for and what's important to us. So we put our core values in the job ad, and then we ask people to apply to an email address with a subject line like "My favorite core value is," and have them fill in the blank.
I've heard a lot of crazy responses over the years. Some people say their favorite core value is blue, or orange. That tells me one of two things: that person is not detail oriented, or maybe their English is not good enough. Either way, I'm not even going to look at those applications. So the number one thing we do when we have tons of applicants is see who really followed the instructions in the job ad, and we immediately delete everyone else. You go from this pool of people to a smaller pool, though the majority will actually follow your instructions.
But here's the thing: don't give people second chances. You might be tempted to think, maybe they misunderstood, what if I'm missing out on a very good candidate because I'm not opening that email? Trust me, you don't want to do this. I wouldn't give people a second chance. I want people who want this job. I want people who double-check and triple-check, and I want their attention to detail. When I was looking for jobs, I did the exact same thing: am I completing everything this company needs? Send this email here, put this in the subject line, cover letter attached, resume attached. I double-checked and triple-checked. That is my standard, so I don't want somebody with a lower standard than mine to apply and represent my company. So mass-delete those who don't follow instructions, without even opening the email.
Cut two: voice recording, portfolio or samples (03:40)
Valentina Brega: The second part of the process: now that you've mass-eliminated the people who didn't follow your instructions, you work with the ones who did. If your job ad was for a voice position (if you're not following this, listen to one of my previous episodes on the job ad and what it should include), we always ask people to send an email with a voice recording when they apply. This is part of the application process. By a voice position I mean virtual assistants who are on the phone: taking inbound calls, doing follow-ups, talking to insurance companies, vendors or clients. If this person is going to represent me on the phone, before I even interview them I want to know what they sound like. So when they apply, I say, put this in the subject line and send us a voice recording. That is for voice positions. For non-voice positions, such as social media, copywriting or video editing, we ask them to send their portfolio.
You design what you want it to look like, but the idea is that to find the person you need, you have to go through elimination steps very quickly. Even at this step, before you interview anyone, you have to understand within ten seconds whether this person is a good fit, or has potential, or doesn't. That's why I ask for a voice recording, a profile, samples or similar before I even look at the resume. I don't care about the resume that much, because let's be honest, people lie on the resume, and now with AI they can have the most ideal resume ever. That's not what I'm going after. I really want to know what you can do for me.
So we listen to the voice recording for five to ten seconds. If this person has potential, good, we keep them. If you don't want that person representing you, delete that email. Don't even look at resumes, don't look at previous experience, because you might fall in love with their previous experience and be tempted to give them a chance, and that's not what we're doing here. You have hundreds of applicants in your inbox, so you've got to move fast.
Our pool of candidates is getting smaller. We started with a big pool where everyone applied, then eliminated those who didn't follow our instructions in the subject line, then those whose voice recording we didn't like or who don't have a good portfolio or work samples. Good, now we have a more manageable pool.
Cut three: resume red flags in dates and job history (06:15)
Valentina Brega: Now, finally, we get to the resume. The mistake most people make is that the first thing they look at is the resume, and that's because they have nothing else to work with. You don't have a voice recording, you don't have a way to know if they're detail oriented, none of what we've covered up to this point. But now, in the fourth step, this is when we look at resumes. Again, give yourself 20 seconds, or ten. If I really like a candidate I will spend more time on the resume, but here are some red flags that should immediately trigger something in me, and I know I probably don't want to work with this person.
Red flag number one: the virtual assistant or employee doesn't list the complete dates of when they worked at a previous company, meaning they don't put the month and the year, only the year. It can be something like "from 2022 until 2023." That might look like a whole year, but what if they started in December and got fired in January, so they only worked one month because of poor performance? Usually there's a reason why people don't include the month. If it worked in their favor, I think they would have put it on the resume. If I see this and I like the candidate overall, I'm not completely saying no yet, but I will address it at the interview. I need to know why there's no month. And if I really, really like the candidate and they go through all of the steps, then I will contact the former employers and get a reference check, or a background check, on how they did in their previous jobs.
The next thing I look at is previous experience. If they worked two months here, two months there, maybe they did put the month, and if they worked two months here and two months everywhere, that is another red flag. It indicates that this is not a stable person. It's okay if you have one or two jobs where people stayed two or three months, because situations happen. But if it's a pattern that continues for years, then I don't think it's a company issue, I think it's a VA issue, or an employee issue, because no company hires to let people go in one month. That's not what companies hire people for. I hire people because I see potential in you, because I see an investment in you, because I want you to grow with me and help me grow. If I let someone go in one or two months, that means you did not give me what I was hoping for. It can happen once or twice, with one or two companies, but not as a pattern, not for years.
Speaking of the timeline, another red flag is an overlap in the times a virtual assistant worked for companies. For example, I see somebody worked from January 2023 until April 2023 in one job, and the other job was from March 2023 until maybe even 2024. Why is there an overlap? My initial thought is: is this why the VA was let go, because they had two or three or multiple clients and could not focus, could not do a good job in one of them? It happens. When your attention is divided, you don't do a good job everywhere, especially if you're hiring people to work for you full time. So to me this is a red flag. Now, there can be a lot of factors. Maybe one company doesn't have enough work and says, "I can only give you 20 hours, but I encourage you to find a different company that will give you more hours." We have had situations like that too. In that case it's okay, and I'm not saying to ignore these people completely, but I want to address it at the interview and ask what exactly happened. Then I will contact the previous companies to get more information about why there was an overlap, and why that person was eventually let go.
Resume red flags in format and focus (10:10)
Valentina Brega: Another red flag for me is bad format, and here's why. I truly believe that how you do anything is how you do everything. The way you show up, the way you talk, you're always on stage. If a person has very high standards, they wouldn't accept something mediocre, especially when it's a resume. When you apply for a job, this is your face card. It represents you. So if you have a bad resume, that usually tells me you might be bad at your job. I might be biased, but we live in an era with AI and a lot of information online, and there's literally no excuse for a candidate to have a bad-looking resume. If they do, that means they're not resourceful. You don't have to be a designer or know everything, because templates are available for free in so many places. There's really no reason to show up with a bad resume. They're not resourceful, they don't care, so they're careless, and again, how you do anything is how you do everything. So this probably tells me you're not going to do a good job in the role I'm hiring you for. Immediately let go of these people, even if on paper they look like they have the right skills. I'm thinking right now about my team: everyone who has been a superstar has had a great resume. That's what I believe.
The last red flag I see on resumes is, you know what they say, jack of all trades, master of none. Unfortunately that's true with VAs and employees as well. I'm all for people having multiple skills, but you can't be an expert in everything. You can't be an expert in bookkeeping and also manage social media like a pro. It just doesn't work. You might have surface-level, general knowledge about everything, and that has its pluses. If that's what you're looking for in a virtual assistant, someone with basic knowledge of bookkeeping, social media, email management and calendar management, that's fine. But if you're looking for a specialist, someone niched, and I see lots and lots of different areas, that's not the person I'm going to hire. If I'm hiring a video editor, for my podcast for example, I don't want somebody who has done sales calls for years, then bookkeeping for a couple of years, and then something else, and who says "by the way, now I'm passionate about video editing." That's just not something that would work for me. I need somebody who lives and breathes video editing, who understands cuts and different elements and music and emotion. That's what I'm looking for.
If you're a virtual assistant listening to this, please tailor your resume to the specific job. I have done other jobs too. I have done sales, and I lead a business, so if I applied for an admin assistant or executive assistant position, I'm sure I could put all my transferable skills into that role. But tailor it: understand what the company needs and showcase your best ability, how you can bring value. Don't talk about everything you've done. It doesn't look that good.
Cut four: the skill test (13:20)
Valentina Brega: We are now at the final part. Let's go back to our funnel: lots of candidates, hundreds of applications in our inbox. We eliminated the ones who didn't follow our subject line. Then we eliminated the ones who didn't have a good voice recording, sample or portfolio. Then we eliminated the ones who didn't have a good resume and had a ton of red flags. What's next? The interview, right? No, that's wrong. Next is a skill test. Put them to a test and understand what they can do for you before you spend time interviewing people. It's not just that you're spending too much time. People will impress you at their interviews. They will say the right thing. You can ask what tools they will use for that, and they will tell you the right tools. You ask how they do this, and they will tell you how. But until you actually work with a person, until you see how their work applies to your product or service, you will not know whether that person is good. So put them to a little test.
I have a previous episode where I talk about different tests you can give. I think I cover ten positions and what test you can give, whether it's an executive assistant, a videographer, content writing or social media. I'll try to link it here, so make sure to check that video. But test their skills, and guess what's going to happen: the majority of the people you shortlisted will not complete the test. They will bail on you. You're lucky if you have 50 percent doing the test, but most likely you won't, and that's okay. You're not wasting time chasing people, asking them or begging them to complete the test. This is how they do things, and if you're not okay with that, good. Focus on those who follow instructions and who work well with you.
Interview only the shortlist (15:00)
Valentina Brega: This is the last step, but it's so crucial. Definitely test the knowledge. After we've gone from so many candidates to a select few, trust me when I say this: if 100 people apply, by the time you're done with the skill test you'll maybe have eight or ten in the best case. But now you can interview ten people, because these ten already went through so much and they're determined. Don't let the screening process take too long. When you look at an application, just quickly understand whether it's a good fit or not a good fit, and send them the test.
I try not to give them a deadline, because I want to see how long it takes people to give it back to me. If you want to give people a deadline, 24 or 48 hours, that's totally up to you. I try not to, because people who really want it will get it done fast. When I applied to jobs and had to do a skill test, I would get it done the same day, and I would brag a little: here's what I can do for you, you want me, you need me in your company, because I am the best employee you'll ever have. I want people with that attitude working for me as well.
So join me next week when we address another topic on how to work with VAs here on the show Built With VAs. I'm your host, Valentina Brega. Thanks for tuning in, see you next time.
Related episodes
- How to Write a Job Ad to Find the Best Candidates
- 10 Ways to Test Your Virtual Assistant (Before You Hire One)
- How to Conduct Successful Interviews for Virtual Assistants
Related on HireTrainVA
Not sure what you need?
Book a call. Tell us where your time goes and we will match you with a VA, an AI Employee, or a Hybrid Team of both.

