10 Ways to Test Your Virtual Assistant (Before You Hire One)
Valentina Brega gives ten practical tests to run before you hire a virtual assistant, one per role: sales, social media, video editing, executive assistant, customer service, data entry, graphic design, bookkeeping, project management and research. She explains what a strong answer sounds like in each, and why a great resume and a smooth interview are not enough on their own.
Key takeaways
- A perfect resume and a good interview do not show what someone can do. HireTrainVA interviews hundreds of candidates to select a handful, and one big reason for rejecting people is that their resume and interview do not match what a short test shows.
- Keep tests fair and short. Give every candidate the same scenario so you compare like with like, and pay for their time if the task is long. The best VAs have options.
- Push past the stock answer. "I'll create folders" or "I'll post more" is what everyone says. Ask what the folders are called, what you would post and why. A real expert has the detail ready.
- Watch speed and quality together. A VA who takes all day for work that someone else finishes in an hour can end up costing more, though for bookkeeping accuracy matters more than speed.
- A true expert does not mind showing their ability. If you cannot run a test, ask what books they read, who they follow and what podcasts they listen to.
About this episode
This is a solo episode of Built With VAs. Valentina Brega, the host, draws on how HireTrainVA screens candidates: the company interviews hundreds of applicants to select a handful. She walks through the test she would use for each of ten roles, including role-playing an angry customer for sales and customer service, asking a data entry candidate to share their screen, and giving a research candidate a task to report back on by the end of the work day. She closes with a story about three team members given the same research task, and with a reminder to be fair and pay people for their time.
Chapters
- 00:00 Introduction
- 00:32 Why you test virtual assistant skills
- 01:42 Test guidelines
- 02:22 Test 1: salespeople
- 03:42 Test 2: social media
- 05:54 Test 3: video editors
- 09:04 Test 4: executive assistants
- 11:16 Test 5: customer service
- 13:50 Test 6: data entry
- 15:09 Tests 7 and 8: graphic design and bookkeeping
- 17:40 Test 9: project management
- 19:27 Test 10: research
- 21:13 Throwing a curveball at my team
- 23:20 Spotting a true expert
- 24:21 Key takeaways
Full transcript
Cleaned from YouTube auto-captions. Filler words and false starts are trimmed, caption errors fixed, speakers labelled from context. Nothing has been added. Timestamps mark the start of each passage.
Introduction (00:00)
Valentina Brega: Before you start working with a virtual assistant, test their skills. Here's what I've noticed: a true expert will not mind showcasing their ability. Even me. I worked in sales for a long time, and if someone told me, "We're going to have a role play on sales," I'd think, all right, let's do it. Today I'm going to give you ten practical tests that you can give to your virtual assistant for different roles. I'll give you a role and the exact test you can use to see if they are the right person for your company.
Why you test virtual assistant skills (00:32)
Valentina: A virtual assistant can impress you with their resume and with great interview skills, and trust me, we've seen it all. At our company, HireTrainVA, we hire and train virtual assistants for other companies. We interview hundreds of candidates to select only a handful, and a big reason we reject candidates is the way they present themselves at the interview or on the resume. They have a perfect resume and perfect interviews, but it's not the same when we put them to a little test. That was a big eye-opener for us.
A lot of people hire a virtual assistant with their emotion. They say, "You have a great resume, a wonderful interview, you're the right person for the job." Then that virtual assistant, or employee (this isn't exclusive to VAs), starts working for you and you get disappointed. So let's see what you can do better as a leader to get better people on board.
Welcome to another episode of Built With VAs. I'm your host, Valentina Brega, and today I'm going to give you ten practical tests that you can give to your virtual assistant for different roles. Let's roll.
Test guidelines (01:42)
Valentina: Before we go into the actual tests, keep in mind that you have to be fair. The tests don't have to be time-consuming. If you're putting the virtual assistant through a lot of hoops, you might have to compensate them for their time. And remember one thing: the best virtual assistants, the A players, have options. To get the best talent you have to speak their language and understand them. So don't give a test that is very lengthy. A couple of minutes to test their knowledge can still give you an idea whether this is the right person for your company.
Test 1: salespeople (02:22)
Valentina: Let's say you're hiring a salesperson. These are the tests we run at HireTrainVA when we hire salespeople. You can have a role play with the VA where you are a customer, and I'd encourage you to be an angry customer. See how your salesperson handles that. When we hire virtual assistants for roles such as callers, any phone service, follow-ups or any lead interaction, we give them a role play where we are an angry customer. We don't want to be mean, but we want to see how the virtual assistant reacts in an uncomfortable situation.
We don't expect virtual assistants to be perfect. No one is perfect, and that's why we have training. When it comes to training, trust me, the majority of virtual assistants have been trained wrong, but that's a different topic for a different episode. So don't put too much pressure on something that can be trained. What I'm curious to see in the role play is how they handle being in an uncomfortable situation. I don't want them to hang up the phone, lose control, stop coming across as an expert or an authority, or get a shaky voice. These are the attributes I want in a good salesperson. You can never train someone for 100% of the scenarios they'll run into, but the basics have to stay the same: no matter what you run into, you need to land on your feet. So give them a role play, be an angry customer, and see how they react. That will give you a better understanding of whether you want that person to sell your product or service.
Test 2: social media (03:42)
Valentina: Number two, social media. You can do something very simple right at the interview. Pull up a profile, maybe your own Instagram, YouTube or Facebook, and ask your virtual assistant: based on what you're seeing, what would you do differently? What do you like about this? What don't you like, and why? Then notice how that person answers. To keep it fair, ask every virtual assistant the exact same questions and the exact same scenario, so you compare apples to apples.
A good expert will know what to do and what not to do. Steer clear of superficial answers. Someone might say, "You don't have a lot of followers, I'll increase the number of followers." Okay, how? What actions would you take? "Well, we need to post more." Post what? If I have to keep asking for more information, this is not the right person for me.
Instead I want somebody confident to say: "I don't understand your target audience. Are you speaking to homeowners or to other real estate agents? Who do you make content for? I don't see an aesthetic, it's all scattered. I don't see a cohesive theme. You talk only about business, and I don't see anything about your family or anything about you as a human being that I can relate to. You don't have any reels. Your reels don't have captions, and a lot of people watch reels without sound, so you still want them to understand the message. Let me see your analytics. How often do you post? When do you post?" A true expert will know all of that and will be able to guide you, even in an interview. That's when I think, okay, I'm willing to give this person a try. If you have that eye and that analytical mind, I want that in my company.
That's the test I would use for social media, but understand what you're hiring for. Maybe you don't need somebody to analyze your social media, maybe you need somebody to design something for you. Then show them a design and ask what they like and don't like about it, and see how they think and what their logic is.
Test 3: video editors (05:54)
Valentina: Number three, video editing. It took us a long time to find a good video editor. We posted ads and our inbox was flooded with applications. Everybody sent portfolios, the portfolios looked great, the interviews went well, and they said all the right things. Then we put them to a little test. I send you a short video of myself, or one of our reels, a one-minute video, and I only want you to edit 10 or 20 seconds. I don't want it to take long. I think you could be done in 15 minutes. Whatever you can do in 15 minutes, that's fine. I want to see how you would use your services on my product and what I have to offer, and then I can see whether I like the aesthetic.
Unfortunately, what I saw is that a lot of people lie, straightforwardly, in their portfolios and in their resumes. A lot of the people who submitted the test were not even at 10% of what I thought they could do based on their portfolios. So it's very important to test the knowledge. Right now we have an amazing virtual assistant who is a video editor, who not only talks the talk but also walks the walk. We love what he's doing, we love the aesthetic and we're in sync with it, and he didn't mind doing this little test.
Some people will mind. Some will say, "Will I be paid for this?" It depends on what you're asking. I always say you have to be fair: if you're asking them to edit a longer video, compensate the VA for their time. If you don't want to, give them a little task they can do during the interview, or in just a couple of minutes, so it's not too taxing on their time. And if they won't perform any task without payment, you can do what we did for social media: show them a video and ask them to critique it. What do they like about it? What don't they like? What would they change? Then notice their answers.
Here are a couple of good things a virtual assistant can say when they look at a video: "This is the wrong music, it doesn't convey the emotion you're going for." "This is the wrong angle." "The cuts are too sharp, they need to be smoother." One thing I look at when hiring a video editor is the storytelling. Sometimes videos have the right cuts and good technique, but there's no soul behind them. It's like an AI did that, and that's not what we need. We need a human being with a mind that tells a story. Sometimes you see beautiful shots that aren't connected, and that's not something we need. People are emotional beings, so if you're making a video, they need to connect with it on an emotional level, especially if it's a creative video. If it's just a podcast, it simply has to deliver value. But if it needs to speak to people's emotions, you need the right audio, the right cut, the right storytelling and the right colors, and the colors need to be graded. That's the kind of information you need from a top video editor. If you don't get that in an interview, then depending on what you need, this might not be the right person for you.
Test 4: executive assistants (09:04)
Valentina: Number four is executive assistant. This is one of the most common positions people hire virtual assistants for. When people come to work with us at HireTrainVA, they often need executive assistants: someone to manage their email and their calendar. I have a whole video on what exactly executive assistants do, so go and check it out. Here's the test you can give. We provide a real-life scenario. I say: you come to work one morning, you open the email, and there are 60,000 messages. What do you do? How do you tackle them? You want to see the level of response.
Everyone will tell you, "I'll create folders." Okay, what kind of folders? Don't be afraid to go deeper. Everyone says they'll create folders because everybody knows that, but to really test the knowledge: what folders, what will their names be, how will you create them? What I would like to see, if I hire an executive assistant to manage my email, is somebody who says: "I want to sit down with you. I'll make a list of everything you're subscribed to and ask: do you need this subscription, do you get value from it, do you want me to delete it, or do you want the messages rolled up just once a month? I want us to be on the same page about what is important to you so I know how to give you value." Encourage people to ask you questions and get on the same page with you. I don't want an executive assistant to manage my email without asking what is important to me. There are newsletters I don't read, but there are some I get a ton of inspiration and good value from, and I want to keep them. So I need my executive assistant to understand that.
In the interview process, this is something I pay attention to: not just creating folders, but the logic behind it. Then the virtual assistant can say something like, "I'll create a folder called 'For Valentina' or 'For the CEO' where I'll put the emails you need to read. When you open your email, instead of seeing 600 messages that I will sort through, I want you to focus only on the 10 or 20 that need your immediate attention right now." If I hear that answer I'll give that person a shot, because they're smart, they have critical thinking, and they understand what it's like working with a busy entrepreneur. I want that person on my team.
Test 5: customer service (11:16)
Valentina: Number five, customer service. How do you test that knowledge? We do the same thing we did for sales: a role play. An angry customer wants to cancel a subscription, or whatever is relevant for your business. How does that virtual assistant handle it? You'll see how they de-escalate problems and what techniques they use.
One thing I look for when we're hiring for customer service is, despite what people think, I don't want them to be overly apologetic or overly sweet on the phone. I want them to be solution oriented. Of course I want empathy. I want them to say, "I'm so sorry you have to go through this, I completely understand. Let me see if I can handle that for you very quickly. My goal is to get it done for you in under two minutes, so I just need a bit of information from you to take care of this problem." Sounds good. See how I want people to have assertiveness and control over the phone? That's what I expect when I call someone.
I recently called a service because they had double charged me for something and I needed to sort it out. The person on the other end was overly apologetic: "I am so sorry, ma'am, you have to go through this." They spoke too much, and as a customer I'm thinking, please just take care of my problem. I don't have a lot of free time. So instead of being too sweet, I want them to be more solution oriented. You can test this with your virtual assistant: ask a question, see how they handle uncomfortable situations. You can also train them, and tell them not to tolerate people who curse at them, because customer service work is not easy and you get angry customers.
I answered phones for a long time, so I know. Some people curse you out, yell at you or call you names. I don't know where you stand on this, but the way I train my virtual assistant is: you don't have to accept this, because you can never say the right thing to the wrong person. If they're angry, they would be angry at anyone. It's not something you said or did. So I would train my VA to say, "Sir, there's no reason for profanity here. In order for me to help you, I need to get some information. If you're not willing to give it to me now, maybe you can call at a later time or I can call you back, but I cannot continue this conversation in this manner and I'm going to have to hang up." That's how I train my virtual assistants, but you decide what works best for you and your business. I could talk about all of this in so much more detail, but let's go to the next one.
Test 6: data entry (13:50)
Valentina: Data entry. Same idea. While you have the person in the interview, ask them to share their screen. Ideally have the task ready, for example entering some data into a spreadsheet. Watch how they handle it, how much time it takes, what their logic is and what steps they take. It's super simple. You don't want to give them access to your website just yet, but a database or a spreadsheet will do, just to see how fast they move.
One thing I look for in a data entry person is whether they know simple shortcuts like Control-C and Control-V, or Command-C and Command-V. If they're right-clicking, choosing copy, going somewhere else and right-clicking to paste, it's a couple of seconds, but it adds up during the day. It tells me that person is not efficient or doesn't know how to be more efficient. You can watch for little things like that when you ask the VA to share their screen during the interview. It doesn't need to take additional time. Just do it during the interview and see if they're the right fit for you.
Tests 7 and 8: graphic design and bookkeeping (15:09)
Valentina: Next one is graphic design. If you have a brand book, this works well. Share your brand colors and what you stand for as a brand with the virtual assistant during the interview. Ask how they would tweak a picture that isn't on brand, or how they would align it with the brand's design. Another thing you can do offline is ask them for an example of their work, such as the kind of aesthetic they would use to design a flyer for you. There are so many templates available now that they don't have to create anything from scratch, so it shouldn't take a virtual assistant long. You see the aesthetic, you see how long it took, and you see whether it's aligned with your brand.
One thing we learned in our company: you might think a virtual assistant is so affordable, much more than hiring someone in the States. That's not always the case. If I can hire someone in the States at twice the price who gets the work done in one hour, that's cheaper than a virtual assistant who takes the whole day for the same thing. When I put the money amount on it, it ends up more expensive to have a virtual assistant on board if they're not efficient. So when I give a task to a virtual assistant, even offline or during the interview process, I want to see how fast they move and how fast they deliver the result. That tells me whether I'm overpaying for the service, or whether I'd be better off hiring someone local who can work faster. Chances are, though, it's humans we're talking about, and you can find a great virtual assistant. Just not the one who takes the whole day. You can find someone else who is efficient and works fast. So definitely test that as well.
Next one is bookkeeping. Give them a small set of different bookkeeping transactions and ask them to record them in bookkeeping software. A spreadsheet is fine too, or maybe they already have software they can use. Again, notice their logic, how they do it and their accuracy, and make sure they don't make mistakes. When you hire a bookkeeper you need someone very attentive to detail and very accurate. Here it's not speed that counts. You don't want somebody taking the whole day, but you don't want somebody rushing through the job either. You want them to do it once and maybe check for accuracy again: look at what you gave them, look at what they put in, and make sure it matches what they entered in the system. That's how I would check for bookkeeping.
Test 9: project management (17:40)
Valentina: Number nine is project management. You give them a hypothetical situation. Say we're working on putting together a retreat for couples. How would you do that? How would you organize it? Where would you keep the information? What milestones would you set? How many people do you need on your team? How would you keep them accountable? I want a virtual assistant to say: "You're looking to put together a retreat. All right, we'll track that in Asana. We'll have the retreat right here and break it down into milestones, so we know the deadline for when the retreat happens, when the landing page needs to be done, when the payment option needs to be available, when people need to buy, how we invite them and which channels we advertise the retreat on."
A project manager has to think about everything: marketing, sales, all of these details. If they give me something very flat like, "I'll delegate this to a team," again, go deeper. What do you mean? Who? What team? How many people do you need? How far in advance will you delegate? Usually I don't like to spoon-feed questions like that. I want them to tell me what needs to happen, because I'm hiring someone who might be better than me.
I'm hiring someone for one of two reasons. One, maybe I'm overwhelmed but I'm very good at this, it just doesn't need to be on my plate. In that case I'll train you and tell you exactly what needs to happen. Or two, I'm not good at this and I'm relying on an expert. In that case, you as the expert had better tell me more details than I already know. You tell me the tools, the systems, the deadlines and everything I need to know, because I'm not the expert. That's something you can test when you're hiring a project manager.
Test 10: research (19:27)
Valentina: Last but not least, research. We have a lot of people who hire virtual assistants for research projects. How do you test that? If people say, "I've done research," it doesn't mean a lot. I need to see how you would do research for me. You probably have the idea by now. There are two ways. Number one, have them share their screen and give them a task, something like: find all the hair salons in the Miami area. See how they find them. Do they run a search on Google? What is their logic? One approach that would be acceptable to me is going to Google Maps and using data scraping tools to put together the hair salons in the area. There are a lot of data scraping tools out there. I want to see how they would solve the problem, so you can ask them to share their screen and follow their process.
Number two, you can ask them at the end of the interview: I need research on this, send it to me in a report by the end of the work day. A lot of the time people will not comply with this, and that's okay. You didn't spend more time on the wrong person. If people don't perform a test I'm not mad. It's a little wasted time to interview them and get them to this point, but I'm glad I'm not wasting any more time.
For the people who do complete the test, look at what kind of report they give you. It should be short, snappy and to the point, maybe communicated in bullet points. Also notice when they send it. I don't want it very fast, but I don't want it at the very last minute of the work day either. It has to be reasonable.
Throwing a curveball at my team (21:13)
Valentina: Let me give you an example. I always throw curveballs to my team. I needed somebody to do research for one of the projects I'm working on, and I tasked three people on my team. I told them what I needed and why, and said to do their best and give me whatever research they could. I chose the three people I thought had potential to take on additional tasks.
One person gave me something very fast, within an hour, but it was superficial. It wasn't exactly what I needed, and he didn't ask me any questions or have an idea of what I needed. So I thought: you're great in your current role, but you're not ready for the next task. If you want to grow, you're just not ready for that yet. The second person took maybe half a day and sent me some good information, but it was a lot of work for me. She did a competitor analysis, and I had to go through it and dig down to find more information. It was a lot more work on my plate and didn't make it easy for me.
The third person is kind of in line with what she's working on anyway in this area, and she gave me exactly what I needed: this is what you're going to do, this is the plan, these are specific things, these are other things other people are doing, this is an example, these are the hashtags you can use. It was so spot on. Even though it took longer, it was so insightful, so good and so organized, in bullet points. I realized, you are definitely the right person for this.
Why am I telling you this long story? Because when you hire a virtual assistant to do research, don't just notice how fast they give it back to you. Notice what kind of information they give you. Is it readable? Is the report concise? Is it exactly to the point, exactly what you need? Or is it giving you more homework, putting more work on your plate, or just very superficial and not interesting at all?
Spotting a true expert (23:20)
Valentina: Here's what I've noticed: a true expert won't mind showcasing their ability. After all ten tests, there are other things you can use for different roles, but one thing stays true. If someone really is an expert, they won't mind showing their ability. Even me. I worked in sales for a long time, and if someone told me, "We're going to have a role play on sales," I'd say, all right, let's do it. If they asked what sales strategies I use, I'd tell them which sales books I read and which podcasts I watch. When you hire an expert, these are people who grow on their skills. If they really are masters of their craft, they'll tell you what they do to hone it, and they won't mind telling you.
If you don't want to give people all of these tests, you can just ask: what books are you reading in this area? Who do you like to follow, why do you like that person, and what do you learn from them? What podcasts do you listen to? All of that gives you a good baseline for whether this virtual assistant or this employee is good enough for you.
Key takeaways (24:21)
Valentina: This was probably a long episode, but I hope you found a lot of good value here. Remember: do not hire anyone before you test what they can do for you, and keep it reasonable. If it's going to take a significant amount of time, pay the virtual assistant for their time. Unfortunately, a lot of virtual assistants get scammed by people, which is very bad, and a lot of talented people are wary of working for free, which is completely understandable. So be reasonable, be fair and have integrity. You work with people, and those people have families and need to provide for them. It's mutual respect, and I promise you, when you find the right person, it makes the biggest difference ever.
I love working with virtual assistants, and I'm sharing how I'm finding top talent. Hopefully you can do the same. As always, we can help you find top talent. If you're looking to work with an agency that has good integrity and amazing success stories of how virtual assistants have helped companies, reach out to us. I'll leave all the information in the description, and I look forward to talking to you next time. See you.
Related episodes
- Sorting Through 100+ Applications? Here's How to Find the Perfect Fit Fast
- How to Conduct Successful Interviews for Virtual Assistants
- 10 Costly Hiring Mistakes
Related on HireTrainVA
Not sure what you need?
Book a call. Tell us where your time goes and we will match you with a VA, an AI Employee, or a Hybrid Team of both.

