Built With VAs podcast

10 Costly Hiring Mistakes

Hosted by Valentina Brega · Episode 40 · July 26, 2024 · 23 min

Valentina Brega goes through ten hiring mistakes, many made at her own company first, including ignoring red flags, skipping skill tests, unclear pay and neglecting the new hire.

Watch on YouTube, or listen on Apple Podcasts and Spotify. Every episode: Built With VAs.

Valentina Brega, founder of HireTrainVA, walks through ten hiring mistakes she has seen, many of them made at her own company first. This solo episode covers red flags, cultural fit, testing skills, paying people, selling your company to good candidates and what happens after the offer letter.

Key takeaways

  • Know what you are delegating and how you will measure it. Valentina says the accountability and KPI side matters as much as the task list.
  • Do not ignore red flags because someone gets results or you feel sorry for them. Her three examples: a person who will not be coached, a skilled person who is toxic for the team, and a person who pads their hours.
  • Hire for cultural fit as well as skill. HireTrainVA hires and lets people go around its core values, which spell VIBE: value, integrity, betterment and excellence, with extreme ownership.
  • Test what candidates can do before you offer the role, and do not wait for a perfect hire. Valentina suggests hiring someone with potential and a personality you like, on a clearly stated 90-day probationary period.
  • Agree pay amount, frequency, platform and who covers fees before onboarding. Then sell your company to good candidates, have more than one person interview, and give a new hire regular meetings and early feedback.

About this episode

This is a solo episode of Built With VAs, hosted by Valentina Brega. She speaks from her own hiring experience, including mistakes her company made in the past and a story about how she chose her own previous employer. She mentions two earlier episodes, one on setting KPIs and one on ten ways to test a virtual assistant before you hire, and points to the free resources at hiretrainva.com/resources.

Chapters

The chapter list on YouTube names the mistakes only by number, so these chapter titles are ours.

Full transcript

Cleaned from YouTube auto-captions. Filler words and false starts are trimmed, caption errors fixed. Nothing has been added. Valentina is the only speaker. Times are the YouTube timestamps for each chapter.

Introduction (00:00)

Valentina Brega: Hiring the right talent is essential for any business. However, the hiring process has a lot of pitfalls that can lead to costly mistakes, and even seasoned managers sometimes make these mistakes, which leads to missed opportunities, wasted time, wasted resources and wasted energy. So let's look into the 10 very costly mistakes that businesses make, and how to avoid them.

Mistake 1: Not knowing what to delegate or how to measure success (00:28)

Valentina Brega: Number one is not knowing what to delegate and how to measure success. A lot of businesses know they need to get things off their plate, but they don't know how to communicate that to a virtual assistant or an employee. For the sake of this episode, because I work with virtual assistants, and this show is called Built With VAs, I will be referring to virtual assistants, but it can be employees, it can be any team members. Let me just focus on the mistake, because this is what a lot of businesses make, and this is definitely something that we made in the past. It cost us a lot to finally understand what didn't go well.

Not knowing what to delegate and not knowing how to measure success, the KPI aspect, the measuring, the accountability piece, is just as important as knowing what to delegate. For you, I have two resources here. I have 100-plus tasks you can delegate to a virtual assistant. Go ahead and check it out for some ideas of things you need to take off your plate. Go through that list, and if you're still doing those things, chances are they shouldn't be on your plate. A virtual assistant can take care of those. I also recently had an episode about KPIs, how to set KPIs based on your goal and what you want to accomplish. I will leave the link here, but make sure to go back and check it. It's super important.

Mistake 2: Ignoring red flags (01:34)

Valentina Brega: Number two is ignoring red flags. How many times have you worked with someone who is not the right person? They're amazing at what they do, they may be very skilled, but they have that toxic trait, or they're not a team player, or you have to walk on eggshells around them, or whatever it is. You ignore these red flags because you always say, "Well, she's a good person," or "He's misunderstood," or "I know his story, I know he's going through this."

Look, sometimes people go through difficult situations. But the way you show up at work, the way you present yourself, is really a choice. Everybody has issues, everybody has problems, but the way you show up and the way you want to work on yourself is going to make a difference. It's okay to have a bad day. It's okay to have a bad week, even. It's perfectly okay. But if this is a continuous pattern, if the VA feels comfortable being in this role and you ignore it because they give you good results, or because you feel sorry for them, then it's not going to be a good person for your team dynamic. Other good people will not like it, will not appreciate it. Don't ignore the red flags.

Red flag 1: A person who is not coachable (02:44)

Valentina Brega: A couple of red flags. Let's say the person is not coachable. The person is super confident in his or her ability and they're not coachable. We actually had a virtual assistant who said, "I don't need any training. I've done sales for 10 years, I don't need any training." Then we put them in that position, and it was the most classic sales mistakes you could ever make. It's so outdated, very pushy. That's not who we are, that's not what represents our company. So people need to be coachable. They need to know what's working, they need to be reading books, they need to constantly hone their craft. That's one red flag.

Red flag 2: Good at the job, toxic for the team (03:17)

Valentina Brega: The second red flag, like I already mentioned, is that they're good at what they do but they're toxic for the team environment overall. We had an experience like that as well.

Red flag 3: Padding the hours (03:26)

Valentina Brega: The third one is they're good overall, they're great with the team, but they cheat on the hours. They say they put in more hours than what they actually work, and you actually have proof. Don't be okay with that. Don't tolerate that. This is a red flag, and you have to have standards that you hold everyone accountable to.

Mistake 3: Ignoring cultural fit (03:45)

Valentina Brega: Number three ties into what we just talked about. A big mistake is that people ignore cultural fit just because someone is good at, say, sales, or good skill-wise, but they're not a good culture fit. This is going to be very, very costly. We actually run personality tests, we have personality profiles. We want to understand that the team dynamic works very well in the company. There are some people who are very good, but if you put together everyone who's assertive and no one wants to follow directions, that's going to be a problem. You need a balance of people who are more assertive, such as managers, for example, and people who love to follow directions, who love SOPs, who love being told what to do. Then you get a much smoother and better team dynamic. You don't need to have all A players in the company. You need somebody to actually do the work as well.

Another thing is if you have somebody who is detail-oriented and somebody who's not, there might be some conflict there. Especially if you have people who are against your core values or who don't match your core values, this is a big red flag for us. It's something that cost us a lot of money, and we try not to make that mistake again.

Our core values (04:55)

Valentina Brega: Our core values as a company spell VIBE. V is value: we bring value in everything we do, in every interaction we have. I is integrity: we do the right thing even when no one is watching. B is betterment: we constantly work on our skills, our personal and professional development. And E is excellence: everything we do has to be excellent, we have to put in all the effort. And also extreme ownership. I'm having a hard time deciding what the E is, extreme ownership or excellence, because both of them are so important to us as a company.

Extreme ownership means you are responsible for whatever is given to you. If it's successful, that's going to be thanks to you. If it's not successful, it's going to be because of you as well. Everything you are assigned, you take full responsibility for. The performance of my team, I'm ultimately responsible for, because I'm the one who hired the team to provide the service. So you get the idea. This is so ingrained in who we are. We hire people around the core values, and we fire people around the core values. I would say most of the people we fired were let go because they're not a cultural fit. They don't want to grow their skills, they don't want to get better at their craft, or they don't bring value, or they don't care enough, or they don't take ownership. They blame everyone else except themselves, which again can be toxic for the team environment.

So this is a very costly mistake. If you're not tackling it, if you're not nipping it in the bud, it can grow into something much worse. You want to make sure you take care of it now, when it's in its infancy.

Mistake 4: Falling in love with a candidate (06:30)

Valentina Brega: All right, number four is falling in love with a candidate. I've seen it, I've done it, I've been there. It's so easy to fall in love with a decent candidate after you've seen hundreds of people, or dozens of people, who are bad. Let me tell you a little secret. When we hire virtual assistants at HireTrainVA, we have to interview about 100 people to find one or two good candidates. It's 98, 99 percent of people who get rejected. So you can imagine that when we find someone decent, we are so excited. Finally, someone who has potential, which is good, but it doesn't mean this is the best person you could have in your company.

So don't fall in love with a candidate yet, because a lot of people lie on their resumes, and a lot of people lie in their interviews. Unfortunately we've seen it happen. I hate to say it, but it happens. Instead, before you offer someone a role, test their knowledge. Fall in love with what they can do for you, not how they present themselves in an interview or on their resume. With AI right now, available people can have the most amazing resumes that follow everything to a tee, and they can really impress you, but it doesn't mean they're the right person.

Mistake 5: Not testing what you buy (07:38)

Valentina Brega: That's actually number five. Another costly mistake is that a lot of people don't test what they buy. A lot of people offer a job opportunity without knowing for a fact what that virtual assistant can do for you. And here's the thing: you never know how good that virtual assistant is until you actually work with them. People can impress you with their resume, they can impress you in their interview, and they can also impress you at the test when you test their skills. They may be a master at their skills, but then when you work with them you realize they don't show up on time, or they're late, or they lie, or there are a lot of other things besides the test. There are a lot of factors that you cannot control during the screening process, and that's normal. But you can control some things. You can lower the number of good candidates that you spend time on, so you don't have to interview the hundreds of candidates who applied to work with you.

One of those things you can control is testing people's skills. It doesn't guarantee that if you test their skills and they're awesome, that person will work out for you, because of a lot of other variables and factors. But this is necessary, at least as a minimum, so that you know they will be good skill-wise. This is something you can test. I made another episode on 10 ways to test your virtual assistant, for 10 different roles: sales, customer service, bookkeeping, a graphic designer, executive assistant, social media. Make sure to check what exactly the test can be. It's probably two or three episodes ago, and I'll leave a link here so you can find it more easily. So that was another costly mistake: not testing what people can offer you.

Mistake 6: Waiting too long to hire (09:26)

Valentina Brega: Number six, another costly mistake, is waiting too long to hire. I see this with our clients at HireTrainVA. They're looking for this perfect, ideal virtual assistant. Let me tell you something: there's no such thing as a super VA. There's no such thing as a perfect virtual assistant, because they grow into being a perfect virtual assistant. You can't hire one, and the reason is that what I consider perfect and what you consider perfect might be a completely different definition. What I think an A player is and what you think an A player is can be a completely different world, because I'm calling someone an A player based on my experience and my expectations, and you're doing the same thing.

When people wait too long to hire, they think that if they hire this one person, they will be a perfect virtual assistant. No such thing. Start them small, give them more tasks, give them more responsibilities, and they will grow into the role. A skill set can be taught, but the personality, the assertiveness, the go-getter quality, the personality traits that you need, hire for that. Then a person can grow into the role you need them to. I'm not saying hire out of desperation, hire someone fast. Don't do that either, that's also a mistake. But waiting to hire the right person can actually be detrimental to your business. You're putting your business on hold until you find the right person.

So what I would recommend is: hire someone who has potential, hire someone whose personality you like, and put them in a 90-day probationary period. Be very clear to your virtual assistant that this is a test for 90 days, or 30 days, or 60 days. Thirty days might not be enough to have somebody show you results. You want to give them time to ramp up, but 90 days is plenty. Set the expectations and monitor the VA's performance. If you have to let the virtual assistant go, they will already know: "Okay, that was a probationary period, I understand I didn't deliver the results you were hoping for." That gives you peace of mind and clarity, and it also helps you hire the right person much faster than waiting too long.

Mistake 7: Not being clear on payment (11:24)

Valentina Brega: Number seven is not being clear on the payment. This is a costly mistake. I remember the story. I liked a candidate who I thought could have a very good impact on my company. I was looking to hire the person for my team, but we couldn't agree on the payment, and especially the payment platform, not so much the amount. We had discussed the amount and everything was fine. But she wanted to be paid on a specific payment platform, and when I looked at it, I had to jump through so many hoops as an entrepreneur. I had to provide all this documentation, which I don't mind, most payment platforms do that anyway, but there were also the fees they charged me. It was just so much on my plate. I spent so much time looking for that option, how to pay that VA and how to go through that, time I could have used doing something else.

This is the lesson I learned from this experience: before you bring anyone on board, make sure you have clarity on how you're going to pay that person. Are you paying weekly, biweekly, monthly? In our company we pay biweekly, so we pay on the 15th and the last day of every month. If a virtual assistant wants to be paid every week, then I have to balance whether it's worth my time, because I'm going to be distracted from my main activity to pay this virtual assistant once a week and then pay somebody else every other week. Or if I have somebody who wants to be paid monthly, again it's a lot of mental space, and I have to analyze whether it's worth it for me. All of these things can be really costly. You can't accommodate everyone. You have to have a standard process, and you have to make sure your virtual assistant is okay with it: the pay amount, the pay frequency, the pay platform, and who's covering the fees associated with the payment platform. In my company, we are the ones covering the payment fees, which sometimes makes us want to look at better, more affordable options. But will that work for the virtual assistant as well? So it's a lot of juggling, a lot of things you have to pay attention to and consider. This can be very costly. You can lose good people if it's not worth it for you. Or sometimes you say, "For that person I'm okay jumping through those hoops just to keep that person happy." But again, it can be a costly mistake not to discuss this up front with a virtual assistant.

Mistake 8: Failing to sell your company (13:40)

Valentina Brega: The next big mistake is failing to sell your company. Remember that an interview or a screening process goes both ways. You want talented people, and guess what, talented people have options. They can work for you or they can work with someone else. They can take their talent anywhere they want and they will not be without a job. So you should not fail to sell your company. Why should they work with you? What's so special about you, what's so unique about your company? Is it the benefits, the culture, the core values you associate with, the pay amount? Do you pay better? I don't know what it is that makes you unique, and it's not always about the payment.

Let me tell you my story. I worked for a real estate investing company before. If you know my story, you know I moved to the United States and I was looking for a job. The first job I got was answering the phone, which was perfect because I didn't have a car and I didn't have a place to live. It was the most stressful period, if you know my story you know exactly what I'm talking about. I saw this opportunity, working from home and answering the phone, and I thought, this is perfect, I don't need a car to go to work. The pay was less than what other companies offered, but I liked the possibility of working from home. For me this was a big selling point, but that's not the reason I chose the company. In the meantime I had other companies offering me work from home, which is perfect, but the reason I chose to work for the real estate company is that at the interview we talked about core values. They shared the growth path with me, they shared the why, the outcome. I resonated with the company's goals, with the outcomes, with what they wanted to achieve, and I could see myself being a critical part in this operation. When they talked about core values, that is exactly what I felt my core values were. They talked about stewardship, growth, integrity and professional development. They asked me what book I'm reading. I told them I was reading the book Traction, which is the book they model their business on. It was so in sync. I was part of that team, they were my tribe, my people, even before I was offered a job. After that interview I told my husband, "I don't care if other companies pay me more. I want to work with this real estate company. I saw myself there, I could feel myself there." The payment wasn't the best, and it was a long schedule, but I could see the growth.

So when you think about this, what do you have to offer to attract A players, to attract talent? Just be yourself, because you want the people who like you for you to apply and work for your organization. I connected with the core values, and it was very comfortable for me to work from home, which was a big plus too, but that's not the main reason I chose that company. And it definitely wasn't the pay, even though we came here and we needed money so badly. I understood that if I was patient enough and started on this path, I could grow so much more and so much faster by being with the right company, and that's exactly what happened. So think about what you have to offer. It's a huge mistake when people only think, "The candidate has to convince me why I should hire them," and they don't think about selling themselves to the great candidate.

Mistake 9: Hiring alone (17:09)

Valentina Brega: Number nine, another costly mistake, is hiring alone. We talked about how you can fall in love with a candidate based on the responses they give you without testing their knowledge. It's so useful to have multiple people from the company interview that person. If it's a Zoom meeting, you can invite maybe the manager of that department to also ask questions and interview people. Why? Because you might see things from a different perspective. You will see things from your perspective. Maybe you're a more emotional person and you will connect with that person's life story and emotion. Maybe the other person on the team is a more logical person and they will say, "I get it, but skill-wise they're lacking this and this and that, and we're going to have to spend so many resources on training this person." So you have different points of view that help you make a more uniform decision on bringing that person on board.

But the main reason I like having multiple people when I hire is that when everybody agrees this is the right person for the team, it decreases the friction or drama that could happen between team members. In our company we have zero tolerance for drama. I'm very blessed to have a completely drama-free environment. No one is talking badly about each other, no one is pointing fingers at each other. We did have a situation like that once, and we had to let that person go very fast. To us this is very important. When you have multiple people from the team interviewing the person, you see who connects with them on a personal level and on a logical level, and whether you can see them working in your department, fitting in your company. It's a much better way to hire the right person.

Mistake 10: Neglecting the new hire (18:50)

Valentina Brega: The last one, and this is a huge one that I see so many times, is neglecting the new hire. You have the right person, you bring them on board, but hiring doesn't end with an offer letter, because now you want that person to bring results to you. I see this especially when people hire virtual assistants, because they're so far away, they live on a different side of the world. People think, "Oh, I hired a VA, I can forget about my responsibility." It's not hire and forget. I always say this. You pour into them, you train them, you give them resources, you become available, you have meetings with them. Yes, at the beginning, whether it's a virtual assistant, an employee or any team member, you want to pour into them, bring them on board, and make sure you're all on the same page.

So don't neglect the new hire. Make sure you have regular meetings. Make sure you give feedback at the beginning of the relationship, not later on when they've already established their way of doing things. It's going to be so much harder to correct their behavior later, as opposed to putting them on the right track early on. It's a huge mistake people make, and trust me, it pays so many more dividends in the future when you invest in the right hire at the beginning.

If people tell me, "Okay, well, what if I put so much energy and time and training into the new person and they leave in six months?" That can happen, and it can happen for a lot of reasons. We're humans, we have emergencies, things can happen. But you can't not train new people. When you train someone, record it and keep the recordings in a safe place. Then when you hire someone new, you can show them the recordings, and you won't have to use a lot of your active time. So there are still a lot of benefits, but you cannot have someone on board and not pay attention to them. Huge mistake.

Key takeaways (20:53)

Valentina Brega: All right, so these are the 10 most common mistakes that I see from my experience when we hire and train virtual assistants. We work with a lot of clients, a lot of companies, and we put so much effort into finding the right virtual assistants. What I realized from my work is that a lot of the clients we work with need a lot of education and a lot of training themselves. A lot of people don't know how to work with virtual assistants, a lot of people don't know what to expect from virtual assistants, and a lot of people don't know how to hire, how to manage, how to train them. This is where we come in. If you're looking for a respectable company that operates with integrity, we would love to see if we're a good fit for you and if we can help you find the right virtual assistant for your company.

Free resources (21:34)

Valentina Brega: If you're looking to hire on your own, I share a lot of good, free information for you on how to do it successfully. It's going to take a lot of your time, and you might not find the right person on the first go, but I promise you it's worth it. Do it again, and continue doing this until you find the right person and avoid these 10 costly mistakes that I just shared with you today. In fact, check my other podcast episodes on how to get the right virtual assistant. I also share a ton of free resources if you go to our website, hiretrainva.com/resources: a ton of free resources on how to work with VAs, SOPs, contracts, what to delegate, how to delegate, tools. It is just so much good information there, and I'm just giving it to you. Just take it and put it to good use. Promise me one good thing: that you will actually use it. I put a lot of effort into making it and making it available for free. A lot of people think, "Oh, if it's free it's not good." That's not the case here, and you will see it.

So do me a huge favor: if you take my free resources, put them to good use and let me know how they helped you. I would be very happy to hear that, to get that kind of feedback and know that I'm doing something to help other business owners. Thank you so much, everyone. As always, everything that I mentioned, check the resources. I will leave all the links to all the episodes and everything I mentioned. Check it here, and I'll see you next time.

Free discovery call

Not sure what you need?

Book a call. Tell us where your time goes and we will match you with a VA, an AI Employee, or a Hybrid Team of both.

Book a call →
Valentina BregaFounder of HireTrainVA · host of the Built With VAs podcast

On Built With VAs, Valentina talks with founders and operators about hiring, delegating and running a remote team, and what actually worked for them.