Built With VAs podcast

7 Hiring Red Flags You Need to Know Before You Hire Anyone

Hosted by Valentina Brega · Episode 55 · January 15, 2025 · 17 min

Valentina Brega lists the seven red flags she watches for in interviews, with the follow-up question she asks for each, and says to look past a perfect-looking resume.

Watch on YouTube, or listen on Apple Podcasts and Spotify. Every episode: Built With VAs.

Valentina Brega, founder of HireTrainVA, lists the seven red flags she watches for when she interviews candidates, whether for a virtual assistant or a local hire. For each one she says what it sounds like in an interview, the follow-up question she asks, and how she spots it early.

Key takeaways

  • A perfect resume does not make a good fit. Valentina says to look past it, because AI tools and resume templates make every resume look good, and the interview shows what the paper hides.
  • The seven flags: vagueness about past roles, job-hopping without clear reasons, badmouthing former employers, over-promising results, unrealistic expectations or no company research, resistance to discussing long-term goals, and poor communication or follow-through.
  • Her counter-move is a follow-up question every time. Ask what problem the candidate was hired to solve, why they left each role, what they personally did about a bad manager, how they would get the result they promise, and how much time they can give your company.
  • She hires for personality first and says skills can be learned, and her company's core value of extreme ownership means she stays away from candidates who blame others.
  • One missed email is not a verdict. Valentina gives a second chance, and passes if the same thing happens again.

About this episode

This is a solo episode of Built With VAs, recorded by Valentina Brega. She says the advice applies to hiring locally as much as to hiring virtual assistants, because the show is about building a team of A players. The red flags are her own, drawn from the interviews she runs for her company, and she asks listeners to send in the ones she missed. The episode is Episode 55, published January 15, 2025, and runs about 17 minutes.

Chapters

Full transcript

Cleaned from YouTube auto-captions. Filler words and false starts are trimmed, caption errors fixed, speakers labelled from context. Nothing has been added. Timestamps mark the start of each passage.

Introduction (00:00)

Valentina Brega: Today I want to talk about the seven red flags you cannot ignore when hiring, and how to spot them. Hiring the wrong candidate isn't just frustrating, it costs a lot of money. It's your company, and you're bringing in people who want to grow it. Welcome to another episode of the show Built With VAs. I'm your host, Valentina Brega, and on this show we talk about how you can scale your company with the help of virtual assistants.

If you're hiring someone locally, the information you'll find on this show applies just as well, because we're talking about how to build a team of A players. So welcome, and let's get started.

Overview: why a good resume is not enough (00:46)

Valentina Brega: Today I want to talk about the seven red flags you cannot ignore when hiring, and how to spot them, especially at the interview. This is going to be spot-on if you have some candidates you might consider hiring and you're not sure if they would be the right people to join your team. Why is that important? Because hiring the wrong candidate isn't just frustrating, it costs a lot of money. You know how much a bad hire costs, right?

Nowadays we have so many AI tools and so many resume templates. When you get an application, the candidate can have a perfect resume that looks great on paper, and you may think this is the right person for the role, the perfect person to solve the problem you're looking to solve. But that doesn't mean they are actually the right fit. To identify a candidate's true potential and avoid future headaches, look beyond the resume. You will see it especially when you have an interview with them, face to face or over Zoom. When you get to talk to them, you see their verbal language, you see their body language, and most importantly, you look for subtleties: something they're not saying with words, but you know this is not the right fit. So here are seven red flags to watch for in your next interview, and quick tips to spot them before it's too late.

Red flag 1: vagueness about past roles (01:59)

Valentina Brega: Number one is vagueness about past roles and responsibilities. If I hear somebody say, "I did a lot of general stuff for the company, helping the team here and there," and they're not telling me specifically what problem they solved, then I'm not sure they know what problem they solved. They did not play a major role in that company. So I often ask at the interview: you worked for such-and-such company, what were you hired to do? What was the problem you were looking to solve? If they hesitate, or it's very general and vague, like "I just did some administration tasks," or "a little bit of this, a little bit of that," okay. Maybe that's true, and maybe it's the management's fault that they never gave that candidate a responsibility or a problem they were solving. But if a person stayed with a company for years, or a significant amount of time, and they don't know what problem they were solving, they were just a placeholder, a filler in the company. They were not an A player and not somebody who contributed to the development of the company. Otherwise I feel they should know how to answer that question properly.

This matters because candidates who struggle to detail past roles may lack real experience, or they may be exaggerating on their resume and didn't actually do what they said they did. The way you can spot it early is by asking questions about each role they had, individually, and insisting on more detail. If you're getting vague answer after vague answer, or they say something like "the fit wasn't right," it may suggest a future turnover risk.

Red flag 2: job-hopping without clear reasons (03:36)

Valentina Brega: The second red flag is frequent job-hopping without clear reasons, and the keywords here are "without clear reasons." If a candidate worked for two months somewhere and then three months somewhere else, sometimes that's normal. Maybe it's not the VA's fault. Maybe it's the management's fault, or the company's. Things happen, businesses pivot and change their strategy, and that's okay. But if this is a pattern that has been going on for years, then the common denominator in all of it is the candidate you're interviewing right now. I wouldn't be sure it's the company's fault. No company hires people to let them go in two months. You hire people because you want them to solve a problem, because you think they will help you grow the company, and nobody can help you grow the company in two months. Like I said, mishaps can happen and directions can change, but if every company that candidate has worked with let the person go, or the person left after two or three months, that's usually a big red flag.

How do you spot it early? First, look at the resume, and don't invite to an interview people who were job-hopping, or whom you think might be, without clear reasons. You can send them an email and ask what the reason was for leaving, but if you send an email, people have a lot of time to think and craft a perfect answer that looks good on paper. So if you get them to an interview, make sure to ask why they left each role. If you get something vague, like "it just wasn't a good fit," or "I was looking for something new," or "I outgrew the company," and the candidate is applying for an entry-level position, something doesn't match. That is definitely a red flag I look for. Career changes are normal, I can see that happens, but it's the frequency of moves without solid reasons that can indicate a lack of commitment, and that is a big red flag for me.

Red flag 3: badmouthing previous employers (05:38)

Valentina Brega: Red flag number three is when they badmouth previous employers or colleagues. Again, I understand that situations happen. I know not every employer is ideal. I know some business owners are just hectic and have no idea what they're doing. I know you're pulled in a lot of directions and you don't have all your ducks in a row, and that's okay. But the way the candidate talks about their previous experience matters a lot. Maybe the manager didn't pay them much attention, maybe they didn't feel appreciated, whatever happened, it's how they talk about their previous employers or colleagues that makes the difference.

If I hear something like, "I left my previous company because my last manager didn't know what he was doing and the team was a mess because of it," my next question would be: what did you do about this? How did you help your manager? What do you mean your manager didn't know what he was doing? Why do you think that? Was it because they were pulled in a lot of directions, or was something else going on? What did you personally do to help the company, or were you just waiting for answers and guidance? For me this is very important, because when I hire someone I'm looking for initiative as well. I hire for personality and I train for skills. Even if somebody doesn't have 100 percent of the skill set I need, that's okay, they will learn if they have the right personality.

So it matters how candidates discuss former employers, because it reveals a lot about their professionalism. Blaming someone else, whether it's the marketing team, the sales team, a colleague, the manager or the supervisor, hints at poor accountability. In our company one of our core values is extreme ownership: before you point fingers at anyone else, you look at yourself and ask what else you could have done to improve the situation. So when I interview people and I see zero ownership and zero accountability, that's a huge red flag, and I stay away from getting that person on the team. Not only because they wouldn't help my company grow, but because I've worked so hard to curate a wonderful team of virtual assistants, and if I bring in a bad apple it can spoil the whole batch. I want to be very careful about who I bring on board.

Red flag 4: over-promising results (07:58)

Valentina Brega: Red flag number four is over-promising results. Have you ever heard this: "I'm confident that I can triple your leads in just a few weeks"? I hear that and I think, okay, that's intriguing, I'd love to hear it. How are you going to do this? "Well, I can't let you know my secrets before I get hired, because then you'll use my secrets and do it yourself and I wouldn't get the job." Well, first of all, that's a scarcity mindset. Second, the ideas you have are probably not unique, so by holding your cards close to your chest and not wanting to share, you're sabotaging your chances of being hired. Second of all, again, it's that scarcity mindset that I'm not sure I want in my company. And third, even if you do share your secrets with me, what is the guarantee that I'll be able to implement them at your level? You claim to be the expert. I don't know how to triple my leads in a few weeks, but if you know how, I would completely trust you to take care of it, because I have a lot of other things on my plate.

So when you hear over-promising and bold statements, take them with a grain of salt. Just go deeper. Ask questions like: how did you do it? Or tell me one strategy. There are probably a lot of strategies, so tell me one thing you did, just so I know we're on the right track, or that I want you to do the same thing for my company. A lot of the time I hear answers that are so vague and so basic that it tells me this person is talking the talk but most likely not walking the walk. If they don't have specific examples or data to back up what they're saying, it could indicate overselling, and then I would have a negative surprise once they start working with me and I find they don't actually know what they said they know. If they can point to data, then their claims might be realistic.

Red flag 5: unrealistic expectations or no company research (09:50)

Valentina Brega: Red flag number five is somewhat close to the last one, but a little different: unrealistic expectations, or lack of company research. If they don't know what my company does, or what my industry is, then again it's overselling on their part. These are the statements I hear: "I'm sure I can completely transform your business within a month," or "I can transform your entire brand within a month," or "I can transform your social media in a month, give me one month." I say, oh, that's awesome, how are you going to do this? How do you know what my customers want? Take the social media example. I want my brand transformed completely in one month, and if I can find that person I would gladly bring them on board. I just don't know how they can do it. So I ask: I love what you're saying, but how do you know what my audience wants? What does my audience actually want? And they have no idea how to respond, or they say something vague, and I'm thinking, no, that's really not what my audience wants, that's not the pain point of my target audience, that probably wouldn't work.

Candidates who make big promises without understanding your business or your customer haven't done their research. So ask what they know about your company's industry, goals and challenges, and about the people you serve, because overly optimistic answers that have no depth might signal a lack of preparation. People will say a lot of good things in interviews, things that sound amazing, but it's up to you to dig deeper and understand if they're legit or if that's just talk.

Red flag 6: resistance to discussing long-term goals (11:42)

Valentina Brega: Red flag number six is resistance to discussing long-term goals. This is something we ask at all of our interviews. Before I bring someone on board, I ask: how much time can you give me and my company? It sounds like a basic question, but it's so good, because you will hear a variety of answers. Some people say, "I'm looking to retire with you, if this is the company I'm looking for. I'm looking for a company I can grow with, for the long term." I actually do have people on my team who say this, and they have been with me for years and are all in and super dedicated. But sometimes I hear, "I'm just focused on the next six months and then I'll see where things go," or "I'm just focused on the next year and then I'll see." So I dive deeper. What's going to happen in the next six months? "Well, I don't know," or whatever answer they give. The way they answer might show you that the job you're offering is just a stepping stone until they find something they're more passionate about. They're working for you for the paycheck, not necessarily because what you offer gives them growth, stability and long-term opportunity. They don't see you that way. They see you as a filler position until they find something they're truly passionate about.

So it all starts with the question I ask at the interview: if you're hired, how much time can you give me, how much time can I rely on you? If I don't hear something long term, that's a red flag and I take a double take at that candidate. I appreciate the honesty, but I have to make sure my vision aligns with theirs. Candidates who don't think long term may lack commitment or direction. Ask about their career aspirations, and evasive answers could mean they're not looking to stay or grow with your team.

Red flag 7: poor communication and follow-through (13:40)

Valentina Brega: Red flag number seven, and this is a huge pet peeve of mine, is poor communication and inconsistent follow-through. Before you bring someone on board, you're probably communicating with the candidate by email. You send the link to your calendar, the invitation to the interview, maybe some documents, and you expect a response. If I get an email that says something like, "Sorry for missing that email, things have been hectic," I don't like it. I know things can be hectic. I'm an entrepreneur, I know things can get in the way, and you probably say the same thing. But if you're applying for a job and it's important to you, you want to make sure you have your ducks in a row, that you're looking out for that email and you reply fast. Inconsistent communication during hiring often reflects poor time management. How candidates do anything is how they do everything, even before you hire them, which is the honeymoon phase, the time when they put their best foot forward, try to impress you and win you over and win that job. If they say, "Now, things have been hectic, I've been super busy," or they have excuses like that all over, it's probably how they're going to communicate with your customers, and with you, once you hire them.

Again, situations can happen. I'm not saying that if you get this email you should fire them or not bring them on board. It's a red flag that needs a little more investigation, and you can spot it early by observing response times and follow-up habits. One time is okay. You can reply, "I get it, I know things can get in the way. Anyway, what I was saying is I would like you to complete this test before bringing you on board," or "I would like you to sign this document before bringing you on board." Give them another chance, and if the same thing happens again, then it's most likely they are not the right fit for you. We're human, we make mistakes, and I understand that can happen to me as well. Maybe that email really was in the spam folder, maybe something really did intervene, maybe I had the flu and couldn't open my email for two days. It happens, I get it. But if that happened to me, I would feel a sense of responsibility, like, oh no, I let that person down, I'd better make sure this doesn't happen again. I would hold myself accountable to deliver better next time. So if you give them a second chance and the next time they don't deliver better, then most likely I would not bring this person on board. I give people chances, but not too many. Fool me once, shame on you, fool me twice, shame on me.

Final thoughts: building a team of A players (16:22)

Valentina Brega: I don't know what else you would add. These are my personal seven red flags that I spot when I interview people, to help me decide whether I want to work with that person or not. Think about this: it's your business, it's your company. You're bringing in people who want to grow it, people who are hungry, people who are skilled, people who have the right personality, people who are coachable and adaptable to change, because businesses change and things pivot. Make sure you bring people who can power through all of that.

Let me know what else you would add. Thank you for tuning in. I would love to read your responses, and I will personally respond to every single comment. If you have any other topics you'd like me to discuss, let me know. I'd love to help you form a team of A players. Help me help you. Let me know what I can do for you. Thank you, I'll see you next time.

Free discovery call

Not sure what you need?

Book a call. Tell us where your time goes and we will match you with a VA, an AI Employee, or a Hybrid Team of both.

Book a call →
Valentina BregaFounder of HireTrainVA · host of the Built With VAs podcast

On Built With VAs, Valentina talks with founders and operators about hiring, delegating and running a remote team, and what actually worked for them.